|

Reading Setauket’s Old Houses From the Road

Setauket and East Setauket hold some of the oldest surviving buildings in the Town of Brookhaven, and most of them can be studied from a public sidewalk or road. A trained eye picks up the clues quickly: the slope of a roof, the number of windows across a facade, the position of a chimney. This guide pairs a short field glossary with real examples in the Three Village area, so the features described below can be matched against buildings that are documented and open to view. For a broader primer on regional styles, an earlier article on Long Island architectural styles covers the vocabulary in more depth.

Video: Three Village Historical Society on YouTube

A note on looking respectfully

Many of the area’s historic houses are private homes. The examples named here are public institutions, house museums or buildings with published addresses. Anyone walking the area should stay on public ways, avoid entering driveways and treat occupied houses as residences first and landmarks second.

The saltbox: the oldest local form

The earliest houses in the area are timber-frame saltboxes, a form with a steeply pitched, asymmetrical gable roof that runs low at the back. The Ward Melville Heritage Organization describes the Brewster House at 18 Runs Road in East Setauket as dating to about 1665 and as the oldest house in the Town of Brookhaven. It began as a one-room cottage and grew into the saltbox seen today; the organization adds that six generations of Brewsters lived there and that Joseph Brewster ran it as a tavern and general store during the Revolution. A 2015 account in TBR News Media notes that the town sold the property to Nathaniel Brewster in October 1665, so the house may be older than the sale record suggests.

Not far in time, the Thompson House at 91 North Country Road is dated to about 1709 in its National Register entry as summarized by Wikipedia. That summary describes a rectangular two-story timber frame with a one-story wing, a steeply pitched asymmetrical gable roof and a central brick chimney, all hallmarks of the type. The Ward Melville Heritage Organization says its education programs there run by appointment and lists no public hours.

A third example sits on Old Post Road. Preservation Long Island says the Sherwood-Jayne house began around 1730 as a lean-to saltbox dwelling and later received a Colonial Revival restoration. Its grounds and nature trail are open sunrise to sunset year round, while house tours run seasonally from June through October.

A colonial saltbox house of the type found in Setauket with shingle siding and a central chimney.

Colonial farmhouses and central chimneys

By around 1800, the farmhouse had become more regular. The Three Village Historical Society’s headquarters at 93 North Country Road, the Bayles-Swezey House, is a two-story farmhouse of about that date, according to the society. A visitor looking for the era’s signature will find a central chimney, a simple gable roof and little ornament. The society’s building was moved to its current site, a detail that shows how often old houses in the area have been relocated and altered.

The society’s exhibit space and gift shop are open Thursday, Saturday and Sunday from noon to 4 p.m. and Friday from 3 to 6 p.m., per the same page, and the Thompson House stands next door. That pairing makes the corner of North Country Road a convenient first stop for comparing a farmhouse of about 1800 with a saltbox of the early 1700s.

Federal features: symmetry and refinement

A field guide prepared for the Cold Spring historic district, which draws on Virginia Savage McAlester’s widely used reference, lists the Federal style as running from about 1780 to 1820. It describes simple box forms, side-gable roofs, doors and windows arranged in strict symmetry, six-over-six double-hung windows and decorative door surrounds with a top light and side lights.

In Setauket, the clearest public example is the Setauket Presbyterian Church at 5 Caroline Avenue. The National Park Service records its style as Federal, with 1812 as a significant date, and the summary on Wikipedia describes a heavy timber frame, wood-shingle siding, a gable roof and a center bay holding a bell tower and entry space. The congregation’s burial ground dates to the 1660s. Its story and its Culper Ring connections are the subject of a separate article on the churchyard.

A Federal-style church and burial ground in the Setauket historic core.

Greek Revival: temple fronts and wide cornices

The same glossary dates the Greek Revival style to about 1825 through 1860. Its hallmarks are a gabled roof facing the front or the side, wide banded cornices with pediment returns, symmetrical facades, columned porches, and an entry framed by narrow transom and sidelights. A Setauket guide published by Untapped Cities describes the historic Setauket Post Office as Greek Revival in style and listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Its proportions can be compared against the glossary features above.

Later nineteenth-century styles

As the century progressed, builders moved toward more elaborate forms. The Cold Spring glossary describes the Italianate style, from about 1840 to 1885, by its low-pitched hipped roofs, wide eaves with brackets, sometimes a square cupola, and tall narrow windows with hoods. Second Empire houses, from about 1855 to 1885, carry a mansard roof, often with dormer windows. Gothic Revival homes use steep roofs with cross gables, pointed-arch windows and sometimes vertical board-and-batten siding, while Queen Anne houses, from about 1875 to 1910, are marked by steep rooflines with front-facing gables, partial shingling and porches with spindlework.

Local history supplies some context for this period. A historical outline on Wikipedia notes that railroad service reached Port Jefferson in 1873 and the Setaukets became a summer resort area. The article does not name particular houses from that period, and this guide does not identify private homes by style. The Three Village Historical Society’s walking guide, reviewed by TBR News Media, explains markers such as inscriptions and plaques and architectural details along a route that runs from the Setauket School to the Emma S. Clark Library, which is a good way to see how the layers fit together.

A colonial farmhouse with six-over-six windows and a stone wall in the Setauket area.

Revival and later buildings

Revival styles soon followed the Victorian period. The Emma S. Clark Memorial Library, built in 1892 and described by Untapped Cities as Tudor in design, is a late nineteenth-century example with a four-foot facade clock. Untapped Cities also calls it the oldest continuously operated public library in Suffolk County, standing on the site of a former tavern and general store. The Cold Spring glossary dates Colonial Revival to about 1880 through 1955 and describes restrained decoration, symmetrical facades and front doors accented by overhangs or side lights. The Sherwood-Jayne house shows how an eighteenth-century form can carry a Colonial Revival restoration.

Where the historic core begins

Wikipedia’s outline of Setauket identifies the Old Setauket Historic District as the historical core around the village green, established after World War II to counter rapid development, with much of the housing stock still pre-war. Caroline Church, from about 1729, stands near the green and is covered in an earlier article. A short loop on foot can take in the church, the Presbyterian churchyard and the surrounding roads. The same Untapped Cities guide lists the Jayne Tavern, built in 1750, moved in 1890 and restored in 1942, among the area’s historic buildings.

A short field checklist

  • Roof first: an asymmetrical gable suggests a saltbox; a mansard suggests Second Empire; steep front gables suggest Queen Anne.
  • Count the bays and note whether windows line up evenly, which points to Federal or Greek Revival.
  • Look at the door: a top light and side lights mark Federal and Greek Revival entries.
  • Check for brackets under the eaves, a hallmark of Italianate houses.
  • Remember that moves, additions and restorations are common; a building may combine several periods.

This article is general information about public architecture and is not a substitute for a professional survey or official historic designation.

Further reading

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Hours, programs and prices change; confirm details with the official sources linked above before visiting.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply