New Listings Near Port Jefferson Station, Selden and Stony Brook: Week of November 12, 2026
Sixteen houses came onto OneKey MLS in the seven days ending November 12, 2026, across six North Shore hamlets of the Town of Brookhaven. Asking prices run from $479,999 for a 616-square-foot 1947 ranch on more than two-thirds of an acre in Port Jefferson Station to $1,200,000 for a seven-bedroom Miller Place colonial with an accessory apartment. Six of the sixteen are in Port Jefferson Station, five are in Selden, two are in Stony Brook, and Mount Sinai, Miller Place and East Setauket have one each. Every house below has its own Maison Pawli Home Profile, with taxes, systems, the school district, the neighborhood and a link to the official listing. The full set, refreshed as profiles are published, sits on the New Listings This Week page.
Video: "Long Island Rail Road Port Jefferson Branch Line Penn Station ⇒ Port Jefferson," World Of Transit on YouTube.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor. Listing data comes from OneKey MLS and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Maison Pawli is not the listing agent for any of these homes.
The week in numbers
Sixteen homes, three school districts and a price spread of about $720,000
The median asking price of the sixteen falls between $679,990 and $685,000, which places half the group below roughly $682,000 and half above it. Colonials are the most common style, with seven of the sixteen, followed by ranches in several forms: straight ranches, a raised ranch, an expanded ranch and a rebuilt custom ranch. Lot sizes stretch from 0.16 acres on Hudson Street in Selden to 1.08 acres on Mount Grey Road in Stony Brook, and build years from 1850 on Main Street in East Setauket to 2002 on Justin Circle in Port Jefferson Station.
Three school districts cover most of the batch: Brookhaven-Comsewogue for the six Port Jefferson Station houses, Middle Country for the five in Selden, and Three Village for the two Stony Brook listings and the East Setauket house. Mount Sinai and Miller Place each have their own union free district. School names appear in each profile as the listing gives them, without ratings.
Two houses advertise accessory apartments, on Wedgewood Lane in Miller Place and on Dorothy Street in Port Jefferson Station, and in both cases the certificate of occupancy and any town permit or rental license are the documents that decide what the second unit legally is. Pools appear at five addresses. Solar appears at two, and neither listing states whether the panels are owned, leased or financed.
Port Jefferson Station: six listings from $479,999 to $975,000
From a 616-square-foot cottage on 0.69 acres to a 2002 house with gas heat and a pool
56 Jefferson Avenue is the least expensive house of the week at $479,999: a two-bedroom, one-bath 1947 ranch of 616 square feet on a lot of 0.69 acres that the remarks describe as flat and cleared. A full unfinished basement holds the laundry, and a covered front porch, patio, fire pit and shed are listed outside. The ratio of land to house is the point of interest here, and anyone weighing an addition would start with the Town of Brookhaven’s zoning and lot-coverage rules for the parcel. Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, OneKey MLS #1072261.
56 Champlain Street asks $599,900 for an extended 1963 split-level with three bedrooms and three full baths on 0.17 acres. The remarks give approximate ages for an updated kitchen, bath, central air, siding, windows, furnace and roof sections, and describe a fully fenced yard with a brick patio, a climate-controlled 10-by-10 shed and a driveway for up to four cars. Listing courtesy of BH&G R E Realty Connect, OneKey MLS #1072292.
38 King Street, at $625,000, is a four-bedroom 1970 colonial of 2,036 square feet with an in-ground pool, pavers, a deck and an outdoor bar area, and a primary bath with a jetted tub, glass shower and skylight. OneHome links a Matterport 3D tour, which is embedded on the profile. Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Integrity Leaders, OneKey MLS #1070374.
34 Dorothy Street asks $685,000 for a 1976 raised ranch on 0.36 acres whose remarks headline a legal one-bedroom accessory apartment with its own entrance. The listing fields, the remarks and public records do not agree on the bedroom count or the square footage, and the profile sets the figures side by side. Listing courtesy of H & G Realty New York, OneKey MLS #1069538.
47 Rodney Street, a four-bedroom, three-bath 1971 colonial of 2,382 square feet at $850,000, carries a 2024 interior update and hardwood floors throughout, per the remarks. The same address appeared on the market in 2024, beginning at $749,888 in June, and the profile traces that earlier price history. Listing courtesy of Premium Group Realty Corp, OneKey MLS #1072198.
18 Justin Circle is the most expensive Port Jefferson Station listing at $975,000 and the newest house of the sixteen, built in 2002, with four bedrooms, two full and two half baths, 2,455 square feet, a fenced in-ground pool, natural gas hot-water heat and public sewer. Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, OneKey MLS #1052237.
Selden: five listings from $485,000 to $755,000

Middle Country homes from a 1950 Cape to a six-bedroom raised ranch with a studio
40 Marshall Drive, at $485,000, is a 1950 Cape Cod of about 1,050 square feet with four bedrooms and one bath on 0.37 acres, and the listing’s own condition field signals that work is expected. Asbestos appears in the construction field as listed, which makes an environmental inspection a reasonable early step. Listing courtesy of The Osorio Group Corp, OneKey MLS #1063539.
15 Corvette Road asks $625,000 for a four-bedroom 1970 colonial on a 0.22-acre corner lot, with every bedroom on the second floor, hardwood floors upstairs and a first-floor home office. Listing courtesy of Exit Realty Liberty, OneKey MLS #1070013.
18 Hudson Street, at $649,000, is a 1998 colonial with four bedrooms, a primary suite with a walk-in closet and en-suite bath, and 1,633 square feet on 0.16 acres. Its data fields list a slab foundation while the remarks describe a finished basement, a mismatch the profile flags for verification. Listing courtesy of Charles Rutenberg Realty Inc, OneKey MLS #1068098.
8 Samuels Lane asks $679,990 for a 1978 colonial of 2,180 square feet on a private dead-end street, with a new roof, Andersen windows, a 200-amp panel and new double garage doors named in the remarks. Who maintains and plows a private street is a question for the title work. Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker American Homes, OneKey MLS #1068181.
65 Dare Road is the largest of the Selden group by bedroom count: a 1972 raised ranch at $755,000 with six bedrooms, five of them on the lower level, three full baths and one half bath, plus a heated and cooled rear studio, an outdoor kitchen and a fire pit. The permit status of the studio and the legality of the lower-level bedrooms are the first items to confirm. Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Rlty Landmark, OneKey MLS #1068590.
Stony Brook and East Setauket: three Three Village listings

An acre with water rights, a rebuilt ranch and an 1850 house on Main Street
11 Mount Grey Road in Stony Brook asks $699,000 for an expanded 1955 ranch with four bedrooms on 1.08 acres, the largest lot of the week, with an in-ground pool, a pool house and a walk-out basement. The remarks name Soundview water rights; their scope and terms are not stated in the listing and belong with the title review. Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, OneKey MLS #1072709.
55 Hopewell Drive, also in Stony Brook, is a 1966 ranch described as rebuilt, at $1,149,000 for three bedrooms, two baths and 1,855 square feet on 0.44 acres. The remarks list a new roof, windows, electrical service and plumbing, a propane combination heat and hot-water unit, Viking appliances and wide oak floors. Listing courtesy of Charles Rutenberg Realty Inc, OneKey MLS #1070144.
381 Main Street in East Setauket is the oldest house of the sixteen, dated to 1850 by both the listing and the remarks. It asks $649,999 for four bedrooms and two and a half baths in 1,651 square feet on 0.35 acres, with wide plank floors, two wood-burning fireplaces, a lower-level kitchen and tavern-style dining room that walk out to a patio, and a detached two-car garage. Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, OneKey MLS #1064899.
Mount Sinai and Miller Place

A ranch with a pool on half an acre and a seven-bedroom colonial
42 Ross Lane in Mount Sinai asks $699,000 for a three-bedroom, two-bath 1977 ranch of 2,102 square feet on 0.53 acres, with a dual-sided fireplace in an oversized great room, an in-ground pool, a gazebo and public sewer. Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, OneKey MLS #1056512.
4 Wedgewood Lane in Miller Place is the highest-priced listing of the week at $1,200,000: a 1972 colonial of 3,860 square feet on 0.52 acres with seven bedrooms counting a two-bedroom accessory apartment, four full baths and one half bath. New siding, a salt-water pool and spa, paver patios, a paver driveway and solar are listed. OneHome shows a recent price change on the listing, and the profile notes the accessory unit and the septic capacity as items to document. Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, OneKey MLS #1069263.
Where to see all of them
Every profile, the official listings and the weekly page
Each Home Profile links to its official OneKey MLS listing on OneHome, where the photographs, any open houses and showing requests live. The sixteen are also gathered in a single OneHome collection, and the New Listings This Week page lists every Home Profile published in the past seven days, across Brookhaven, Smithtown and the East End. The complete archive is on the Home Profiles page.
Readers comparing these hamlets can turn to the side-by-side Setauket, Port Jefferson and Stony Brook comparison and the North Shore neighborhoods guide, and anyone preparing an offer can start with The Complete Guide to Buying a Home on Long Island’s North Shore.
Listings are courtesy of the listing brokerages named on each Home Profile. Data is sourced from OneKey MLS and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed; prices, status and details change, and buyers should verify all information independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor. Maison Pawli supports the Fair Housing Act and equal opportunity in housing.
Sources
- OneKey MLS collection of the sixteen listings on OneHome
- 42 Ross Lane, Mount Sinai — Home Profile
- 4 Wedgewood Lane, Miller Place — Home Profile
- 381 Main Street, East Setauket — Home Profile
- 11 Mount Grey Road, Stony Brook — Home Profile
- 55 Hopewell Drive, Stony Brook — Home Profile
- 56 Jefferson Avenue, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 56 Champlain Street, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 38 King Street, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 34 Dorothy Street, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 47 Rodney Street, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 18 Justin Circle, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
- 15 Corvette Road, Selden — Home Profile
- 65 Dare Road, Selden — Home Profile
- 18 Hudson Street, Selden — Home Profile
- 40 Marshall Drive, Selden — Home Profile
- 8 Samuels Lane, Selden — Home Profile
- World Of Transit, “Long Island Rail Road Port Jefferson Branch Line Penn Station ⇒ Port Jefferson,” YouTube
