34 Dorothy Street, Port Jefferson Station — Home Profile
For Sale $685,000 · 3 Beds · 2 Baths · 2,200 Sq Ft · 0.36 Acres · Built 1976 · Legal Accessory Apartment
34 Dorothy Street in Port Jefferson Station is a raised ranch listed at $685,000 in OneKey MLS #1069538. Per the listing, the house was built in 1976 on 0.36 acres and has a two-car garage, oil-fired hot water baseboard heat, public water and a cesspool. The headline fact is the accessory apartment: the remarks call it a legal one-bedroom unit with its own entrance and its own parking area.
The data fields show three bedrooms, two full baths and 2,200 square feet, while the remarks headline reads four bedrooms and two bathrooms, counting the apartment’s bedroom and bath alongside the main house’s three and one. The listing was two days old on OneHome when this profile was prepared, with 38 photos posted and four listing documents attached.
Property Details
The Basics
- Property Type: Single Family Residence
- Style: Raised Ranch
- Bedrooms: 3 in the data fields (the remarks headline counts 4, including the accessory apartment)
- Bathrooms: 2 Full (main house 1, accessory apartment 1, per the remarks)
- Living Area: 2,200 sq ft (per the listing; see the note on public-record square footage below)
- Lot Size: 0.36 acres
- Year Built: 1976
- Construction: Frame, shake siding and vinyl siding
- Foundation: Concrete perimeter
- Garage: 2 spaces
- HOA: None stated (Association: No)
Systems & Utilities
- Heating: Hot water baseboard, oil (the remarks list a new oil tank and a newer boiler)
- Cooling: Wall/window units
- Water Source: Public
- Sewer: Cesspool
- Utilities: Cable, electricity and phone available; public trash collection
- Electrical: 200-amp service (per the remarks)
- Other: In-ground sprinkler system (per the remarks)
- Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.
The Accessory Apartment
The remarks describe a legal one-bedroom accessory apartment with a full kitchen, a living room, a large bathroom, a private entrance and a dedicated parking area. The listing does not state whether the apartment has its own meter, who currently occupies it, or what license or certificate of occupancy covers it. Per Greater Long Island’s report on the Town of Brookhaven’s 2024 amendments, the town’s accessory apartment framework covers one-bedroom apartments in owner-occupied homes, issues the license alongside the certificate of occupancy, and renews licenses on a two-year cycle. A buyer can ask the Town of Brookhaven building division for the apartment’s license, its certificate of occupancy and its renewal status, and can have an attorney review how the license carries over at closing.
Rental Income Language in the Remarks
The remarks mention potential rental income from the apartment. The listing gives no lease, rent figure or tax treatment, and no income is shown or promised here. Brookhaven’s licensing rules, any owner-occupancy requirement and the tax consequences of renting a unit are matters for the town and for a licensed attorney or tax professional.
Square Footage and Bedroom Counts
Three figures differ across sources. The listing data shows 2,200 square feet and three bedrooms; the remarks headline counts four bedrooms; and PropertyShark’s public-record page lists 1,812 square feet and describes the parcel as a one-family year-round residence with accessory apartment. The difference may reflect how the apartment area and garage-level space are counted. A buyer can ask for floor plans and confirm the measured square footage, since price-per-square-foot figures depend on which number is used.
Systems and Updates Named in the Remarks
The remarks list a new oil tank, a new hot water heater, a newer boiler and newer windows, plus 200-amp electrical service and an in-ground sprinkler system. No installation dates, permits or warranties are stated. Heat is oil and sewage goes to a cesspool, so a buyer can request tank and boiler service records and a cesspool inspection.
Listing History and Public Records
OneHome shows ‘New Listing’ status with two days on the platform, 38 photos and four attached listing documents, which were not reviewed for this profile. No open house is listed. The price history and tax history panels were locked behind a sign-in and showed placeholder values only. PropertyShark’s public-record page shows a deed with a document date of October 3, 2024 and no recorded price, and a mortgage recorded April 18, 2025 with the amount redacted. The same page puts the 2025-2026 market value at $617,925 and the assessed value at $3,275, and it shows two different property tax figures ($10,564 and $13,024), so tax records should be confirmed directly.
Tax & Financial Data
Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.
- List Price: $685,000
- Price Per Sq Ft: about $311
- Annual Property Taxes: $12,993 (tax year 2026, per the listing)
- Tax Assessed Value: $3,275 (assessment-roll figure, not a market value)
- Tax ID: 0200-180-00-01-00-054-000
- MLS#: 1069538
The assessed value is not an appraisal. Public-record sites show differing tax figures for this parcel, so confirm current taxes, exemptions and any STAR eligibility with the Town of Brookhaven receiver of taxes.
School District
The listing places the home in the Brookhaven-Comsewogue school district. Named schools are Norwood Avenue School, John F Kennedy Middle School and Comsewogue High School. School assignment is set by the district, so enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.
The Neighborhood
Port Jefferson Station is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven, bounded on the north by the railroad tracks that separate it from the Village of Port Jefferson, according to Wikipedia’s Port Jefferson Station entry. The same source says the area was first called Comsewogue, a Native American name, that the Long Island Rail Road arrived in 1873 and gave the hamlet its present name, and that suburban growth followed the construction of Nesconset Highway in the mid-1950s. The Port Jefferson station is the terminus of the LIRR Port Jefferson Branch, opened January 13, 1873, with diesel-only service. The listing gives Old Town as the cross street, and OneHome’s neighborhood panel shows a Walk Score of 25 (‘most errands require a car’), a Bike Score of 49 and a Transit Score of 82.
What Stands Out in the Listing
Legal accessory apartment. The remarks stress a separate one-bedroom unit with its own entrance and parking. The license, certificate of occupancy and renewal status are the documents to request.
Conflicting size and bedroom figures. The data fields, the remarks headline and public records do not agree on bedrooms or square footage, so floor plans and measurements are worth requesting.
Mechanical updates named. A new oil tank, new hot water heater, newer boiler and windows and 200-amp service appear in the remarks, without dates.
Cesspool and oil heat. Sewage is handled by a cesspool and heat is oil, two systems with their own inspection and service records.
Next Steps for 34 Dorothy Street
View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.
Listing courtesy of H & G Realty New York, Joseph Russo · OneKey MLS #1069538. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Street View image: Google, July 2024. Map data © Google.
Sources
- OneKey MLS listing #1069538 on OneHome
- Greater Long Island: Brookhaven enacts accessory apartment code changes
- PropertyShark: 34 Dorothy St public record
- Wikipedia: Port Jefferson Station, New York
- Wikipedia: Port Jefferson station (LIRR)
- Google Maps Street View, 34 Dorothy Street (July 2024 capture)
