381 Main Street, East Setauket — Home Profile

Illustrated drawing of 381 Main Street, East Setauket, New York, made for the Maison Pawli Home Profile. A representation of the home, not a photograph.For Sale

$649,999 · 4 Beds · 2 Full + 1 Half Baths · 1,651 Sq Ft · 0.35 Acres · Built 1850

Google Street View near 381 Main Street, East Setauket, NY. The view and imagery date may differ from the property today. © Google.

381 Main Street in East Setauket is a Colonial the listing dates to 1850, offered at $649,999 in OneKey MLS #1064899. Per the listing, it has four bedrooms, two full bathrooms and one half bathroom in 1,651 square feet on 0.35 acres, with clapboard siding and a detached two-car garage.

The remarks describe wide plank flooring, two wood-burning fireplaces, a lower-level kitchen with a tavern-style dining room that walks out to a patio, a parlor with built-in bookshelves and a Juliet balcony, and a full basement with a stack-stone and cement foundation and 12-foot ceilings. The seller’s agent invites buyers to ‘bring your paintbrush and imagination,’ which signals cosmetic work.

Property Details

The Basics

  • Property Type: Single Family Residence
  • Style: Colonial
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2 Full, 1 Half
  • Living Area: 1,651 sq ft (per the listing)
  • Lot Size: 0.35 acres
  • Year Built: 1850 (per the listing)
  • Construction: Clapboard, frame
  • Garage: 2 spaces (detached, per the remarks)
  • Basement: Full, stack-stone and cement foundation, 12-foot ceilings (per the remarks)
  • Fireplaces: 2 wood-burning (per the remarks)
  • HOA: None stated (Association: No)

Systems & Utilities

  • Heating: Oil
  • Cooling: None
  • Laundry: Washer and dryer hookups
  • Water Source: Public
  • Sewer: Cesspool (public sewer also shows as connected in the utilities line; confirm which applies)
  • Utilities: Electricity, water and public trash collection connected
  • Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.

An 1850 House: Age-Related Questions

The listing gives 1850 as the build year, and the remarks describe the house as an 1850’s colonial. A house of that age raises standard questions that the listing does not answer: the age and capacity of the electrical service, whether any knob-and-tube wiring remains, the condition of the foundation and sills, plumbing materials, and whether lead-based paint disclosures apply. A buyer can ask whether lead-based paint disclosures apply to a pre-1978 home and request any inspection reports the seller holds. This item may warrant attorney review of the contract rider.

Two Kitchens and a Third-Floor Kitchenette

The remarks place the kitchen on the lower level and describe a kitchenette on the third floor next to two bedrooms and a full bath. The listing does not state whether the kitchenette is permitted or whether the house is approved as a one-family dwelling with a second cooking area. A buyer can check the certificate of occupancy and any permits with the Town of Brookhaven building division.

Fireplaces, Oil Heat and No Central Air

Two wood-burning fireplaces are listed. Heat is oil and cooling is listed as none. Chimney inspections and an oil system evaluation are common requests for homes of this age, and no cooling system is listed.

Listing History and Public Records

OneHome shows the listing as new, with one day on the platform, and lists one open house on Saturday, November 14, 2026 from 1:30 PM to 3:30 PM, with refreshments noted. The price history and tax history panels on OneHome were locked behind a sign-in and showed placeholder figures, so no earlier sale is reported here. A buyer can request prior deed records from the Suffolk County Clerk and building permit history from the Town of Brookhaven.

Tax & Financial Data

Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.

  • List Price: $649,999
  • Price Per Sq Ft: about $394
  • Annual Property Taxes: $6,967 (tax year 2026, per the listing)
  • Tax Assessed Value: $1,600 (town assessment figure, not a market value)
  • Tax ID: 0205-009-00-01-00-013-000
  • MLS#: 1064899

Confirm current taxes and any exemptions with the Town of Brookhaven receiver of taxes. If the property sits in a historic or landmark district, additional review rules could apply to exterior work; the listing does not say.

School District

The listing places the home in the Three Village Central School District. Named schools are Setauket Elementary School, Paul J. Gelinas Junior High School and Ward Melville Senior High School. Enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.

The Neighborhood

East Setauket is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven covering about 6.08 square miles, with a 2020 census population of 10,998, according to Wikipedia’s East Setauket entry. That page notes the c. 1665 Brewster House within East Setauket and Stony Brook University to the west. Neighboring Setauket’s village green was the site of the 1777 Battle of Setauket, per Wikipedia’s Setauket entry, which also describes the Culper Spy Ring, whose members were mostly Setauket residents. OneHome’s neighborhood panel shows a Walk Score of 36, a Bike Score of 85 and a Transit Score of 81.

What Stands Out in the Listing

1850 build year. The listing and remarks both date the house to 1850, with wide plank flooring and two wood-burning fireplaces.

Lower-level kitchen with patio walk-out. The remarks place the kitchen and a tavern-style dining room on the lower level with a walk-out to the patio.

Basement and detached garage. A full basement with 12-foot ceilings and a detached two-car garage are described, along with a fully fenced backyard.

Cosmetic updating expected. The remarks open with an invitation to bring a paintbrush, which points to cosmetic work; the condition of systems is not stated.

Next Steps for 381 Main Street

View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Lisa A. Jaeger · OneKey MLS #1064899. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.

Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. No Street View image is used because mature trees and hedges hide most of the house from the street in the available capture (July 2024).

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply