Craft Beverage Stops Near Port Jefferson and Setauket

Port Jefferson and Setauket sit between two different drinks scenes. Locally, a small number of brewery taprooms operate in Port Jefferson and Port Jefferson Station, and the better-known wine country lies farther east on the North Fork. This guide covers what the official sites and recent news reports say about each stop, from the nearest taprooms to wineries on Sound Avenue and in Jamesport. It leaves out places whose own sites could not be checked, which is why the cider section is short. Drinking-age rules apply at every stop, and this article is general information only.

Video: FOX 5 New York on YouTube

Montauk Brewing Co. in downtown Port Jefferson

The most recent addition is a Montauk Brewing taproom at 22 Mill Creek Road. The News 12 report from June 1, 2026 said the East End brewer was taking over the former Port Jeff Brewing Co. building near Main Street, which closed in November after 15 years. The Brewer Magazine described a six-year lease and a space of about 800 square feet, the company’s first satellite beyond its original Brew Barn in Montauk.

An August 17, 2026 citybiz article reported that the location had opened, with a ribbon cutting on Wednesday, August 19, from 5 to 7 p.m., involving the Port Jefferson Chamber of Commerce. It named Wave Chaser IPA and The Surf Beer among the beers served, with seasonal releases such as Summer Ale and Watermelon Session Ale. The article did not say whether beer is brewed on site, and it did not mention food.

The company’s own site calls the Port Jefferson taproom Downport and lists the address as 22 Mill Creek Road, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, phone (631) 483-0085. Posted hours are noon to 8 p.m. Monday through Thursday, noon to 9 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and noon to 7 p.m. Sunday. The core lineup shown there includes Wave Chaser IPA, The Surf Beer, Juicy IPA, a pilsner, Tropical IPA, Belgian White, Cold Day IPA and Pumpkin Ale, along with two non-alcoholic options. The page does not say which beers are on tap on a given day or whether food is available, so those answers need a call or a look at the brewery’s on-tap page.

Craft brewery taproom bar with beer taps near Port Jefferson.

Po’Boy Brewery in Port Jefferson Station

Po’Boy Brewery operates in Port Jefferson Station. Its website describes a tasting room serving craft beer and cider, with a menu updated weekly. Hours listed when the page was reviewed ran from 2 to 7 p.m. on Monday and Tuesday, 4:30 to 9:30 p.m. on Wednesday, 4:30 to 10 p.m. on Thursday, 4:30 to 11 p.m. on Friday, noon to 11 p.m. on Saturday and noon to 7 p.m. on Sunday. The phone number is (631) 828-1131, and the site does not list a street address in its main text.

The brewery mentions chili cookoffs and an annual Halloween bash among its events, though its events page showed no scheduled dates and asked visitors to check back, so any event should be confirmed directly with the brewery. Po’Boy also appears on a News 12 page as one of the winners of its Brewery Battle series.

A note on cider

Po’Boy is the only stop above that lists cider on its own website. Dedicated cideries exist on Long Island, but none near Port Jefferson or Setauket could be confirmed from an official page for this guide, and an older report on a Calverton cider house could not be matched to a current site. Visitors looking specifically for cider may do better asking the tasting rooms about seasonal pours, or using the regional trail resources described below.

A South Shore brewpub for a longer drive

Blue Point Brewing, in Patchogue, is a longer trip across the island. Its website describes a brewpub attached to the brewery, with a classic beer portfolio, seasonal beers, beer cocktails and special brews from an innovation room. Fresh-shucked oysters are featured, and a food menu is posted. Brewpub hours when reviewed were noon to 8 p.m. on Sunday, closed Monday, 3 to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday, and noon to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Live music has its own calendar, and the site notes that it is for visitors of legal drinking age. The page does not mention brewery tours.

Tasting flight of craft beers of the kind poured at Port Jefferson taprooms.

North Fork and Sound Avenue wineries

Wine tasting on Long Island is concentrated on the North Fork, and the Long Island Wine Country site offers a directory of wineries along with itineraries and events. It features Palmer Vineyards at 5120 Sound Avenue in Riverhead, RGNY at 6025 Sound Avenue and Baiting Hollow Farm Vineyard at 2114 Sound Avenue in Calverton. The drive from Port Jefferson is considerably longer than the trip to either taproom, so these stops suit a planned outing more than an impromptu one.

The Palmer Vineyards site says the tasting room is open year-round and accepts walk-ins, though wine club members and guests with reservations are seated first. Reservations are required for parties larger than six on weekends and are not required Monday through Thursday. The phone number is (631) 722-9463, and current hours and the tasting menu are on the winery’s visit page.

Sherwood House Vineyards, at 1291 Main Road in Jamesport, describes tastings in a renovated 1870s farmhouse, with wine by the glass or bottle on a back patio. Its website lists hours of 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Friday and 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. on weekends, and says outside food is not permitted. Reservations last one hour, every member of a party must take a tasting flight, and reservations are strongly encouraged for parties of six or more. The site carries a notice that it is under construction, which is a reason to call at 631-779-2817 before driving.

Regional resources

For stops beyond those above, New York State’s tourism site has a page on the Long Island Craft Beverage Trail that calls Long Island a destination for craft beverage fans and cites dozens of breweries, fifty wineries and a distillery that uses Long Island potatoes. The page does not list member businesses, and it points to a trail website at discoverlongisland.com for the roster. Because producers open, close and change owners, as the Port Jefferson taproom change shows, a roster is a starting point and each business’s own page is the final word.

North Fork vineyard rows in autumn near the Sound Avenue wineries.

Planning a visit

A few practical points apply across these stops. Hours differ by day and by season, and the figures above are snapshots from mid-October 2026. Food policies vary: Montauk’s page does not mention food, Sherwood House bars outside food, and Blue Point runs a kitchen. Parking in downtown Port Jefferson often means the Town of Brookhaven marina lot at 118 West Broadway, which a Chamber page on Town parking lists at $4 per hour Monday through Thursday and $5 per hour Friday through Sunday and holidays. Anyone planning to sample more than one tasting room may want to arrange a ride or a designated driver in advance, and Montauk’s non-alcoholic N.A. IPA and N.A. Golden give designated drivers something to order. Groups traveling by bus or limousine to Sherwood House are directed to arrive between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m. with an advance reservation, and parties of 13 or more can contact the winery about small events.

Visitors to the downtown taproom can add a walk to a drink. The village’s visitor site describes Harborfront Park as combining green space with waterfront views, and it lists more than 60 shops and boutiques, which makes a browse along Main Street a natural companion to a tasting in the village.

Village events can fill a day around a taproom visit. The Harvest Festival runs October 17 and 18, and the Chowder Crawl on Saturday, October 24 runs from noon to 3 p.m. with 13 participating restaurants. Neither listing says anything about breweries, so those events and a taproom stop are separate plans.

Related reading

Further reading

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Hours, programs and prices change; confirm details with the official sources linked above before visiting.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply