Port Jefferson Station Market Report: October 2026
Port Jefferson Station closed August with a median sale price of $649,570, 2.6% above the same month last year, on 22 sales — a 13.4% rise in volume — and homes went to contract at 102.1% of their asking price, according to Redfin’s Port Jefferson Station housing data. The county picture a month later says the same thing in a larger frame. OneKey MLS, the regional listing service, reports a September single-family median of $740,000 across Suffolk, up 2.8% year over year, with closed sales up 4.6% and days on market down to 40 from 44 (OneKey MLS Suffolk County Local Market Update, September 2026).
Two numbers in that release matter more than the median. New single-family listings in Suffolk fell 5.6% from a year ago, and inventory fell 2.9%, to 3,220 homes. Fewer houses came on, and fewer are sitting. That is the condition Port Jefferson Station sellers have been working in all year, and it explains why the town’s sale-to-list ratio is above 100% for the second autumn running.
What the county numbers say
The OneKey report, current as of October 7, breaks Suffolk into three property types. The single-family line is the one that describes Port Jefferson Station, where detached houses on quarter-acre lots are most of the housing stock.

| Single-family, Suffolk County | Sep 2025 | Sep 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| New listings | 1,364 | 1,287 | −5.6% |
| Closed sales | 995 | 1,041 | +4.6% |
| Days on market until sale | 44 | 40 | −9.1% |
| Median sales price | $720,000 | $740,000 | +2.8% |
| Percent of original list price received | 100.5% | 101.0% | +0.5% |
| Inventory of homes for sale | 3,315 | 3,220 | −2.9% |
Source: OneKey MLS Suffolk County Local Market Update, September 2026. The report notes that price figures do not account for sale concessions or down-payment assistance.
Condos moved differently. The Suffolk condo median jumped 12.6%, to $582,500, on 8.1% fewer sales, and condo inventory dropped 16.5%. In Port Jefferson Station that segment is small — a handful of complexes off Route 112 and near the Terryville Road corridor — but the squeeze on supply is the same story at a sharper angle.
Where Port Jefferson Station sits inside that
Port Jefferson Station’s median runs about $90,000 below the Suffolk single-family figure. That gap is the reason the town keeps drawing buyers who have been priced out of Setauket and Port Jefferson village, where comparable houses clear $800,000 with regularity. A three-bedroom ranch in Comsewogue or a cape in Terryville is still a house a two-income household can finance, and the LIRR station on Route 112 puts Penn Station a little over two hours away without a car.
The town’s median days on market in August was 34, per Redfin — 13 days longer than a year earlier, even as prices and sales rose. That is not a contradiction. More sales at a slower pace usually means more houses coming on than the year before, and buyers having a little more time to compare. Correctly priced listings are still going to contract in two or three weeks; the ones taking longer are mostly the ones that opened high.
The pricing conversation has changed. In 2024 a Port Jefferson Station seller could list at the top of the range and expect the market to meet it. This fall, a listing that is 5% over the comparable sales draws showings and no offers, and the price cut that follows costs more than the overreach gained. A seller’s first number has to be the right number.
The ownership picture behind the numbers
Public records tell something the sales data does not. Thousands of Port Jefferson Station homes have been in the same hands for twenty years or more, bought in the early 2000s or before, and many of them carry little or no mortgage. The owners are often the original purchasers, now in their sixties and seventies, in houses larger than they need. That equity is the single biggest reason this market keeps producing listings even when rates discourage buyers who have a 3% loan from moving.
For an owner in that position, the question is rarely whether the house will sell. It will. The question is timing — whether to go in the spring, when competition is heaviest, or in late winter, when inventory is at its low and a well-prepared house has the field to itself. The last two years, January and February listings in the Three Village and Port Jefferson area have drawn the strongest sale-to-list ratios of the calendar.
What buyers are finding
Buyers in Port Jefferson Station this fall are seeing a clear split. Updated houses — new kitchen, new roof, central air — go fast and often over asking. Houses that need the work are sitting, and they are the ones negotiating. A buyer willing to take on a 1960s kitchen and original windows can still get a Comsewogue cape for under $600,000, which is becoming rare on the North Shore. Suffolk County’s down-payment assistance program and the state’s SONYMA loans apply here, and Port Jefferson Station’s price point is one of the few on the North Shore where those programs still reach a detached house.

Interest rates remain the other half of the equation. Every half-point move changes what the same monthly payment buys, which is why buyers who were waiting in the spring have come back in the fall, and why a seller who lists now meets a deeper pool than one who listed in June.
What to watch through the end of the year
Three things will shape the Port Jefferson Station market between now and the spring.
The first is the Suffolk inventory number. If new listings keep running 5% below the prior year, prices hold through the winter even if sales slow. If the January listing wave is larger than usual, the 102% sale-to-list ratio comes down.
The second is the Lawrence Aviation site. The county, the MTA and the Town of Brookhaven have spent years working toward a rail yard and open-space plan on the former Superfund site off Sheep Pasture Road. Any firm step there — a signed agreement, a construction date — changes the long-term read on the north end of Port Jefferson Station.
The third is the condo squeeze. With condo inventory down 16.5% county-wide and the median up 12.6%, the handful of Port Jefferson Station complexes are likely to see the strongest percentage gains in the area over the next twelve months, which matters for owners who bought those units as a first home a decade ago.
Getting a number for your own house
County medians and town averages describe the market, not a specific house. A 1,400-square-foot ranch on a 0.35-acre lot in Middle Park Homes and a 2,400-square-foot colonial on Jayne Boulevard are in the same town and the same report and are worth very different amounts. Pawli prepares a written market estimate for any Port Jefferson Station home from comparable closed sales, at no cost and with no obligation. Hablamos español.

For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor. This article is general information and does not constitute an appraisal or an offer of brokerage services.
