Apples and Cider Near Setauket: Orchards and Stands
A News 12 segment from 2017 opens with the observation that Long Island’s North Shore was once covered in apple orchards, with a cider mill in each town. Few of those remain near Setauket itself. Cornell Cooperative Extension Suffolk County’s 2018 farm stand list includes Brookhaven-area stands such as Glover Farms in Brookhaven and HeartBeet Farms in Centereach, but none of the stands it lists around Setauket, Stony Brook or Port Jefferson shows apples or cider among its products. For fruit and pressed cider, the options lie farther east along Sound Avenue and the North Fork, or west in Northport.
This guide covers apple-focused stops rather than pumpkin patches, which are the subject of a separate article, North Shore pumpkin picking and farm stands. Several listings below come from articles written in earlier years and are marked as such.
When apples are available
Apple picking on Long Island generally runs from late August into October, with varieties ripening at different times. The PickYourOwn.org Long Island listing describes Lewin Farms picking from late August through late October and Woodside Farms offering more than ten varieties as they ripen in September and October. The same listing advises calling first because conditions can change overnight, and it notes that some orchards pick only on weekends or holidays.
Payment and container rules vary. According to that listing, a few farms accept cash only, and Wickham’s Fruit Farm requires its own containers and a family membership for pick-your-own at $20 a year. The listing carries update dates from 2019 to 2023, so these rules should be treated as a starting point and confirmed with each farm.
Harbes: apples, cider donuts and hard cider
Harbes Family Farm is the one orchard operator in this group whose own website reports 2026 season information. According to the Harbes site, Harbes Orchard at 5698 Sound Avenue in Riverhead offers apple and pumpkin picking and is open daily through November 1, with weekday hours of 10 AM to 6 PM and weekend hours of 9 AM to 6 PM. Harbes Farms Jamesport, at 1223 NY-25, offers Honeycrisp picking on weekends and holidays through the same date.
The cider angle comes from two other locations. Apple cider donuts are made fresh daily at the Mattituck Farmstand, 715 Sound Avenue, using real apple cider, and hard cider is served alongside wines in the Harbes Vineyard tasting room. The farmstand also sells farm-grown produce, including apples, with weekday hours of 10 AM to 6 PM and weekend hours of 9 AM to 6 PM, and the orchard lists live music from noon to 5 PM on weekends and holidays. The farm gives telephone numbers for each location, including 631-683-8388 for the orchard and 631-482-7641 for Mattituck.

Calverton and Wading River stops
Several farms cluster around Calverton and Wading River, along Sound Avenue, Middle Country Road and Route 25A. A 2023 News 12 guide lists Lewin Farms at 812 Sound Avenue, with Gala, Honeycrisp and Macoun apples, and Windy Acres Farms at 3810 Middle Country Road in Calverton, with about 30 varieties, including Golden Delicious, Mutsu, Granny Smith and McIntosh.
A 2022 Northforker article on cider doughnuts adds details. It calls Windy Acres a fifth-generation family farm with a farm stand and weekend pick-your-own, and it describes Bakewicz Farms at 291 NY-25A in Wading River as a place to take treats to go or eat them at The Silo with local craft beer or cider. Hallock’s Cider Mill at 1960 Main Road in Laurel is described as a family-owned roadside market with cider doughnuts and an apple-pie-filled option.
The 2022 and 2023 descriptions above were not confirmed on current farm websites, so the 2026 season and hours need checking before a trip.
A cider press on the North Fork
Wickham’s Fruit Farm in Cutchogue is the most documented cider producer in the area. A Suffolk Times feature reports that the farm has pressed its own cider for more than 50 years on a press built in 1904, which came from the former Billard Farm after owner Irving Billard sold it to the Wickhams in the early 1960s. The farm manager is quoted there as saying the press has never missed a season. A 2022 News 12 segment describes apple cider doughnuts, candied apples, apple turnovers and apple pie among its products.
The Suffolk Times article is undated and appears to be several years old, so current offerings are best confirmed with the farm at 631-734-6441, the number given in the PickYourOwn listing.

Northport: Richters Orchard
West of Setauket, Richters Orchard on Pulaski Road in Northport has a long record. An ABC7 report from 2015 states that the orchard has operated since 1900 and is run by brothers Louis and Andrew Amsler and their family, who have been Long Island fruit growers since 1934. A 2017 News 12 piece is titled for the orchard and its cider mill, and Northforker’s list of Long Island farms marks Richters as having a farm stand with apples and cider. The listing on Orange Pippin says visitors are welcome and advises calling ahead for opening times.
Hard cider tastings
For fermented cider, Riverhead Ciderhouse at 2711 Sound Avenue is listed by I LOVE NY as an 8,000-square-foot space with a tasting room, retail area, café and two large fireplaces, serving ciders made from New York State apples. A Northforker feature on the ciderhouse names twelve flavors on tap. Woodside Orchards is described in the Northforker article reviewed here as offering hard cider tastings, and Harbes’ vineyard room serves hard cider as noted above. Hours are not posted on the I LOVE NY page, so the ciderhouse’s telephone number, (631) 591-0217, is the way to confirm.
Farther east and west
Beyond Calverton, the News 12 guide cited above lists a longer run of pick-your-own farms. Breeze Hill Farm & Preserve at 31215 County Road 48 in Peconic is credited with 26 apple varieties, and Woodside Orchards at 116 Manor Lane in Jamesport with 28 types, including Cortland, Empire, Fuji, Gala and Ginger Gold, plus cider and hard cider tastings. On the South Fork, the guide names the Milk Pail U-Pick Farm at 50 Horsemill Lane in Water Mill, with Jonamac, McIntosh, Sansa and Zestar apples, and Hank’s PumpkinTown on Montauk Highway. Going the other direction, Jericho Cider Mill at 213 Route 106 in Jericho is on the list without further detail. These are longer drives than the Sound Avenue stops, and the listed varieties reflect a 2023 snapshot.

Questions to settle before driving out
The PickYourOwn listing points to several practical differences between farms. Harbes requires admission to enter the farm and does not take reservations. The Milk Pail has no public restrooms and no longer allows dogs, and Wickham’s and Hank’s have their own pet or parking rules. Several orchards use dwarf or semi-dwarf trees, which keeps most fruit within reach, and Harbes uses a trellis system. Whether picking is open on a given weekday, whether a farm limits pickers to its own containers and how it takes payment are worth asking when calling.
Closer to Setauket
The Three Village Historical Society’s farmers market, listed on its 2026 calendar, begins May 1 and ends on October 30, so the final market of the 2026 season comes at the end of October. The calendar does not list vendors, and whether any sell apples or cider is a question for the society. The Glover Farms stand, covered in the pumpkin article, also appears on the Extension’s farm stand list with daily hours of 10 AM to 6 PM in 2018.
Related reading
This article offers general information about farms and public venues and is not an endorsement of any business.
Further reading
- The Apple Lover’s Cookbook: a related title for this activity. See it on Amazon (affiliate link)
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Hours, programs and prices change; confirm details with the official sources linked above before visiting.
Sources
- 2018 Suffolk County Farm Stand List (Cornell Cooperative Extension Suffolk County)
- Long Island apple orchards (PickYourOwn.org)
- Harbes Family Farm
- Where to go apple picking on Long Island (News 12)
- Where to find apple cider doughnuts on the North Fork (Northforker)
- How Wickham's Fruit Farm makes its apple cider (Suffolk Times)
- East End: Wickham's Fruit Farm in Cutchogue (News 12)
- Apple picking season at one of Long Island's favorite orchards (ABC7)
- Long Island's Hidden Past: Richter's Orchard and Cider Mill (News 12)
- Richters Orchards (Orange Pippin)
- The Riverhead Ciderhouse (I LOVE NY)
- Riverhead Ciderhouse feature (Northforker)
- Apple picking guide (Northforker)
- Three Village Historical Society events
