New York Kitchens Catch Fire 4.6 Times as Often on Thanksgiving
On Thanksgiving Day 2024, fire departments across the United States answered an estimated 1,139 home cooking fires, according to the National Fire Protection Association. That is 321 percent of the daily average, which works out to roughly 355 cooking fires on an ordinary day. Christmas is a distant second: Christmas Day and Christmas Eve, the next two, run at nearly twice the average.
New York Runs Hotter Than the Nation
A state-by-state count from federal fire reports
The NFPA figure is national. A state breakdown arrived this month from MoneyGeek, which analyzed seven years of reports that fire departments filed with the U.S. Fire Administration’s National Fire Incident Reporting System, 2019 through 2025. The analysis compared each state’s Thanksgiving Day residential cooking fires with that same state’s average on ordinary November days, leaving out the holiday stretch from the Wednesday before Thanksgiving through the following Sunday, and Veterans Day.
Nationally, departments reported 3.72 times as many residential cooking fires on Thanksgiving as on a typical November day. New York came in well above that, at 4.58 times, fifth highest of the 31 states with enough consistent reporting to include. Its departments logged 1,475 Thanksgiving cooking fires across the years counted; one year, 2021, was dropped by the analysis because of a break in the state’s reporting.
The largest jumps came mostly in the Northeast, with California the exception:
- Rhode Island: 6.22 times its November average
- New Jersey: 5.30 times
- California: 4.98 times
- New York: 4.58 times, fifth of 31
Southern states took all five of the smallest increases, with Alabama lowest at 2.01 times. The ratio measures the size of the holiday spike against each state’s own baseline, so a state with many cooking fires all year can show a smaller Thanksgiving jump than a state where kitchens are usually quiet.

What Starts the Fires
Unattended cooking leads every list
The NFPA’s summary is blunt about the cause: “Unattended cooking was by far the leading contributing factor in cooking fires and fire deaths.” Cooking accounts for half of all reported home fires, 51 percent by the association’s count, along with 35 percent of home fire injuries and 16 percent of home fire deaths. On Thanksgiving specifically, 80 percent of structure fires are cooking fires, and those cooking fires account for 35 percent of the civilian injuries in Thanksgiving structure fires, based on annual estimates for 2020 through 2024. The same estimates record no civilian deaths in Thanksgiving cooking fires over those five years.
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission works from its own estimates. In its holiday release last November, the agency said cooking accounts for about 45 percent of annual residential fires and that Thanksgiving Day averages about 1,400 cooking fires, more than three times a normal day. The CPSC’s figures come from its Residential Fire and Loss Estimates and NFPA’s from its own annual estimates, so the counts do not match.
Across a whole year the scale is larger. In a November 2022 holiday release, the agency put home cooking fires at an estimated 165,600 a year, leading to about 200 deaths and 3,200 injuries annually.
The Turkey Fryer Split
The fire protection group and the federal regulator part ways on frying
Turkey fryers are where the two sources divide. The NFPA’s position is unqualified: it strongly discourages turkey fryers that use cooking oil, recommending a fried turkey from a grocery store or restaurant, or a fryer that does not use oil.
The CPSC takes a different tack. Its 2025 holiday release offers rules for frying, built around the acronym COOK: carefully follow the manufacturer’s instructions, never overheat the oil, never overfill the fryer, and keep it out of the garage, off the deck and away from the house. A November 2022 CPSC release counted 217 fire or scald and burn incidents involving turkey fryers since 2000, resulting in 83 injuries and $9.5 million in property loss.

What a Cooking Fire Costs
An average loss above $73,000 in one insurer’s claims
The financial side of a cooking fire can be large. State Farm reported in November 2025 that it had paid nearly $234 million for indoor and outdoor cooking fire losses from January 2024 through November 2025, with an average loss of more than $73,000. Georgia topped its state list at $19.6 million. New York did not appear in that top ten.
Georgia led State Farm’s list of total cooking fire losses, but in the MoneyGeek analysis of fire department reports, its Thanksgiving increase ranked 23rd of 31 states, at 2.50 times its November baseline. State Farm’s totals track its own claims across all of 2024 and most of 2025, not a single holiday, so a large book of business in one state can top the dollar list while that state’s Thanksgiving jump stays modest. New York, absent from the insurer’s top ten, has one of the steepest holiday jumps in the fire department data.
For owners who later sell, past damage can come up again on paper; the earlier Maison Pawli guide to reading the New York seller disclosure covers how that form works.
The Smoke Alarm Check
The cheapest protection in the house
Last on the NFPA’s Thanksgiving list is the most familiar item: make sure smoke alarms are working, by pushing the test button. Maison Pawli’s guide to testing and maintaining smoke and carbon monoxide alarms covers the monthly test, battery types and replacement schedule, and a separate review looks at one 10-year combination alarm.
The rest of the NFPA list is practical and specific: stay in the kitchen while anything is on the stovetop, stay in the house while the turkey roasts and check it often, keep children at least three feet from the stove, and keep cords from electric knives, coffee makers and mixers from dangling within reach.

You Might Also Like
- How to Test and Maintain Your Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarms
- Kidde P3010K Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm Review
- Winterizing a Long Island Home Before the First Hard Freeze
Sources
- National Fire Protection Association: Thanksgiving Safety Tips and Fire Statistics
- MoneyGeek (Nathan Paulus): Thanksgiving Cooking Fires by State (November 18, 2026)
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission: Put Safety on the Menu (November 19, 2025)
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission: Holiday Safety Release (November 21, 2022)
- State Farm: Releases Latest Cooking Fire Statistics (November 24, 2025)
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not insurance or legal advice. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
