187 Middle Highway, East Hampton — Home Profile

Illustrated drawing of 187 Middle Highway, East Hampton, New York, made for the Maison Pawli Home Profile. A representation of the home, not a photograph.For Sale

$2,495,000 · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Full Baths · 3,450 sq ft · Modern · Built 1982 · 3.14 Acres

Map of 187 Middle Highway, East Hampton, NY. Map data © Google.

187 Middle Highway in East Hampton is a five-bedroom, four-bath house of about 3,450 square feet on 3.14 acres, listed in OneKey MLS at $2,495,000. The remarks describe a second-floor living and dining area with a soaring ceiling and double-height windows, a clay tennis court, a primary bedroom on the first floor with a steam shower, and room on the land for a pool and pool house.

The listing is framed around potential: the remarks say a buyer could “renovate, expand, or build anew.” A December 2025 James Lane Post item shows the same house marketed earlier at $2,700,000, and OneHome lists six documents attached to the current listing.

Property Details

The Basics

  • Style: Modern (an earlier press item describes a Salt Box-style house with vertical cedar siding)
  • Year built: 1982
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Bathrooms: 4 full
  • Living area: 3,450 sq ft
  • Lot size: 3.14 acres, described as landscaped
  • Rooms total: 12
  • Layout per the remarks: three guest bedrooms, a hall bath and a primary suite on the first floor; a second-floor living room and dining area with a loft; lower level with recreation room, full bath and walk-out
  • Garage: 1-car attached
  • Basement: partial
  • Fireplace: wood burning stove
  • Exterior details listed: balconies, fire pit, tennis court, wood siding; faces south; view of trees and woods
  • Appliances listed: dryer, dishwasher, oven, range, refrigerator, washer

Systems & Utilities

  • Heating: oil; the utilities line also reads “natural gas connected,” so the fuel needs confirming
  • Cooling: wall and window units
  • Sewer: septic tank
  • Water source: private
  • Solar: the remarks mention solar panels, without stating whether they are owned or leased
  • Laundry: washer and dryer hookups
  • HOA: none
  • Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.

The Tennis Court and the Open Acreage

The remarks list a clay tennis court on the 3.1-acre lot and say there is “ample room to add a luxurious swimming pool and pool house.” A December 2025 James Lane Post item on the same address described a “pristine HydroCourt clay tennis court,” a bright, expanded Salt Box-style home with vertical cedar siding, and a $2,700,000 price, with listing agent Dana Trotter of The Agency named in that earlier item.

A pool, pool house or any expansion on this lot would need approval under the Town of East Hampton’s building and zoning rules, and the lot’s coverage limits, setbacks and any wetlands considerations are questions for the town and a land-use attorney. The listing does not state a zoning district. This point may need review by a real estate attorney.

Septic, Private Well and Solar

The fields list a septic tank and a private water source. A private well and an on-site septic system call for their own tests: a water-quality test and an inspection of the septic system are standard items for a buyer to request, along with the Suffolk County Department of Health Services records for the parcel. The remarks mention solar panels. If the panels are leased or financed, the lease or power purchase agreement and any transfer terms are documents to read before closing.

The heating fields give oil, while the utilities field reads “natural gas connected.” The listing does not say whether gas serves the house, and the heating fuel and equipment age are best confirmed with the seller side.

Listing Documents on OneHome

OneHome states that six documents are attached to this listing, and the page offers a View Documents link. The documents were not read for this profile, and their contents are not summarized here. A buyer reviewing the listing can open them from the official listing page, which may include disclosures, surveys or floor plans.

Listing History and Public Records

OneHome shows a list price of $2,495,000, a New Listing banner and 4 days on OneHome, with 33 photos. The price and tax history tables on the OneHome page show placeholder values to a visitor who is not signed in. A December 2, 2025 James Lane Post item, listed in the sources, shows the address marketed at $2,700,000 at that time. No sale history was found on the pages read.

Tax & Financial Data

Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.

  • List Price: $2,495,000
  • Price Per Sq Ft: about $723
  • Annual property taxes: not shown on the OneHome page available for this profile
  • Tax year: not shown
  • MLS#: 1069331

Taxes and the assessed value were not visible on the listing page. Confirm the current bill with the Town of East Hampton Receiver of Taxes and ask whether the solar installation affects the assessment.

School District

Per the listing, the home is in the East Hampton school district. The named schools are John M. Marshall Elementary School, East Hampton Middle School and East Hampton High School. School assignment depends on district boundaries and should be confirmed directly with the district.

The Neighborhood

The village of East Hampton was founded in 1648 by farmers who first called the settlement Maidstone, and it was incorporated in 1920, according to Wikipedia’s entry for the village,_New_York). The Montauk Branch of the Long Island Rail Road reached East Hampton in 1895. The village’s ocean beaches run, west to east, from Georgica to Main Beach, Wiborg, Egypt Lane and Two Mile Hollow, with parking restricted from May 1 to September 30. The remarks place the house close to East Hampton Village shops and restaurants, farm stands, trails and beaches; the address is in the 11937 ZIP code, and whether it falls inside the incorporated village or elsewhere in the Town of East Hampton is a point to check on the tax bill.

What Stands Out in the Listing

Acreage and a clay court. 3.14 acres with a clay tennis court and room for a pool and pool house per the remarks.

First-floor primary suite. The primary bedroom opens to a wisteria-covered patio and has a steam shower, per the remarks.

Second-floor living area. A living and dining area with a soaring ceiling and double-height windows leads to a rear balcony.

Private well and septic. Neither public water nor sewer is listed.

Earlier price. A December 2025 press item shows $2,700,000 for the same address.

Next Steps for 187 Middle Highway

View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.

Listing courtesy of Sothebys Int’l Realty Hamptons, Garrett P. Shea · OneKey MLS #1069331. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.

Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. No Street View image is used because Google shows no imagery at the address.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply