Huntington vs. Smithtown: Two North Shore Towns, One Rail Line
Huntington and Smithtown share a rail line, a county, and a shoreline on Long Island Sound, and a search for either name turns up two overlapping meanings: the large town, and the smaller hamlet at its center. Sorting those meanings out comes before any comparison of homes, prices, or commutes, because most of the published numbers describe one geography or the other.
Town, Hamlet, and Why the Numbers Disagree
The Town of Huntington, according to its Wikipedia entry, recorded a 2020 census population of 204,127, and the name also covers a hamlet and census-designated place inside the town, which is the town seat. The Town of Smithtown follows the same pattern on a smaller scale, with a 2020 population of 116,296 and a separate Smithtown census-designated place within its borders.
Real estate websites rarely say which of these they mean. A page headed “Huntington” may describe the hamlet, the ZIP code, or the town, and the same is true of “Smithtown,” so a figure that looks like a disagreement between sources often reflects nothing more than different boundaries drawn around different sets of sales.
Two other hamlets belong to Smithtown’s story. Kings Park and St. James both lie within the town, and both have their own stations on the Long Island Rail Road.
Huntington: Harbor Town and Rail Junction
Huntington’s history runs back to a 1653 land purchase whose eastern boundary was Northport Harbor, with Cold Spring Harbor on the west, and the town’s harbors supported agriculture and shipping before the railroad changed the economy. Cold Spring Harbor became a popular summer resort once trains arrived, and the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, where James D. Watson served as chancellor, remains one of the area’s best-known institutions.
The Heckscher Museum of Art and Walt Whitman’s birthplace anchor the cultural side of the town, and the Huntington station is the point where the Port Jefferson Branch changes character: it is the eastern end of electrification, so trains west of the station run electric while trains east of it run diesel. The Maison Pawli breakdown of the Port Jefferson Branch explains how that split shapes frequency and transfers.

Smithtown: Main Street and the Bull
Smithtown organizes itself around Main Street and Jericho Turnpike. The large bull statue known as “Whisper” stands at the fork where Jericho Turnpike meets St. Johnland Road, and while the legend attached to it is a local favorite, local historians consider that story a myth. The Town Hall on Main Street dates to 1912, the Smithtown Performing Arts Center sits at 2 East Main Street, and St. Catherine of Siena Medical Center is located in the hamlet.
Rail access comes through three stations on the Port Jefferson Branch: Kings Park, Smithtown, and St. James. All three sit east of Huntington, on the diesel portion of the line, where the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s archived service description puts off-peak service at roughly one train every 90 minutes. Riders heading to Manhattan generally change trains at Huntington or Jamaica, a pattern covered in the Long Island commuting guide.
What Recent Sale Prices Show
Prices in both places rest on modest numbers of monthly sales, and the sources below measure different slices of each market, so the figures are best read as snapshots rather than a ranking.
- Huntington: a Redfin median sale price of $953,500 as of February 2026, up 10.5 percent year over year, as reported in a 2026 market report that also cites a Huntington Station median of $617,500 for the same month.
- Huntington, January 2026: City-Stats, drawing on Redfin data, listed a $1,120,000 median sale price for January 2026 across 17 homes sold, a figure that sits well above the February number from the other source and illustrates how much a handful of sales can move a monthly median.
- Smithtown, November 2025: a Redfin median of $999,900, up 38.0 percent year over year, with 19 homes sold.
- Smithtown, January 2026: City-Stats, again citing Redfin, listed a median of $827,000 with 15 homes sold.
The gap inside each market, roughly $173,000 between two Smithtown readings two months apart, is the more useful finding than any single number. Monthly medians in towns of this size jump when a few high-priced homes close in the same month, and neither place can be summarized by one figure.

Lining Up the Differences
On the evidence gathered, the two towns differ in scale and in rail position more than in character. Huntington is the larger town, holds the point where the line shifts from electric to diesel, and has more frequent service on its side of that divide. Smithtown is smaller, sits on the less frequent diesel portion, and spreads three stations across its hamlets.
Buyers weighing the two usually find that the questions that matter most are not about the towns at all: how a specific street relates to a station, how a specific property handles flood and insurance questions, and what a given block has sold for recently. The broader context lives in the North Shore neighborhoods guide, and the neighboring harbor communities to the east are compared in the Maison Pawli piece on Setauket, Port Jefferson, and Stony Brook.

Sources
- Huntington, New York — Wikipedia
- Smithtown, New York — Wikipedia
- MTA: LIRR Port Jefferson Branch service
- Leave the Key: 2026 Real Estate Market Report, Huntington, NY
- City-Stats: Housing in Huntington, NY
- City-Stats: Housing in Smithtown, NY
- Redfin: Smithtown housing market
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal, tax, or financial advice, a valuation, or an offer. Market figures are dated snapshots from third-party sources and are not guarantees of future prices. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
