21 Rustic Road, Miller Place — Home Profile
For Sale $699,000 List Price · 5 Bedrooms · 5 Full Baths (per the data) · 2,519 Sq Ft · 0.36 Acres · 1970 Year Built
21 Rustic Road is a 1970 Colonial on 0.36 acres in Miller Place, listed at $699,000. The listing data gives five bedrooms, five full baths and 2,519 square feet, an attached two-car garage, a full finished basement and one fireplace. The remarks describe hardwood floors, a kitchen with white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances and a center island, and a rear deck with a fire pit area on a lawn with mature trees.
Two things shape the questions below: the remarks and the data disagree on the number of baths, and public records show the house sold in early 2025. A video of the house made for an earlier listing in 2022 also survives on YouTube.
Property Details
The Basics
- Style: Contemporary, Colonial per the data
- Bedrooms: 5
- Bathrooms: 5 full per the data; the remarks describe 3 baths
- Living Area: 2,519 sq ft
- Rooms: 12 total
- Lot Size: 0.36 acres (15,682 per an IDX copy of the listing, unit not labeled)
- Year Built: 1970
- Interior: Hardwood floors, ceiling fans, kitchen with center island per the remarks
- Appliances: Dishwasher, gas range, microwave, oven, refrigerator
- Fireplace: 1
- Basement: Full, finished
- Attic: None
- Garage: Attached, 2-car
- Outdoor: Deck, fire pit area per the remarks
- Fencing: Vinyl
- Construction: Frame
- HOA: None
Systems & Utilities
- Heating: Oil
- Cooling: Central air
- Water: Public
- Sewer: Cesspool
- Laundry: In hall
- Utilities: Electricity and phone connected, water available
- Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.
Three Baths or Five
The remarks call the house a “5-bedroom, 3-bath Colonial,” while the structured MLS data lists five full bathrooms, and the IDX copy repeats the five. A 2024 listing record for the same address on raveis.com also showed five full baths. A buyer would count the baths at a showing and compare the result with the certificate of occupancy and any permits on file with the Town of Brookhaven, since the difference matters for appraisal and for the cesspool capacity the house relies on.
An Earlier Listing Video
The video below was posted in October 2022 by Video Studio by Compass for an earlier listing of 21 Rustic Road. Its description from that time calls the house a four-bedroom Colonial of close to 3,000 square feet, which does not match the current data, so the interior shown may not reflect the house as offered now. The current listing on OneHome has 36 photos and no video or tour.
Listing History and Public Records
OneHome shows the listing as new, with 2 days on OneHome when the page was read, 36 photos and no upcoming open houses. The Coldwell Banker Homes page for the current listing shows it listed on November 4, 2026 at $699,000 and records a sale on February 25, 2025 for $795,000 per public record. A Coldwell Banker Homes page for the earlier listing (MLS L3590152, Island Advantage Realty) shows it listed on November 8, 2024 at $799,900 and sold on March 6, 2025 for $775,000. The two sources give different sale dates and prices, so a buyer would confirm the recorded deed with the Suffolk County Clerk.
Tax & Financial Data
Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.
- List Price: $699,000
- Price Per Sq Ft: about $277
- Annual Property Tax: $18,426 (tax year 2025, per the listing)
- Tax ID: 0200-048-00-07-00-021-000
- MLS#: 1070333
The tax figure is for 2025 and comes from the listing; it would be confirmed with the Town of Brookhaven receiver of taxes.
School District
The listing places the address in the Miller Place school district and names these schools.
- Elementary: Andrew Muller Primary School
- Middle School: North Country Road School
- High School: Miller Place High School
School boundaries are for reference only and can change. Enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.
The Neighborhood
Location. Miller Place is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven with 11,723 residents at the 2020 census, per Wikipedia. It takes its name from the Miller family; Andrew Miller, a cooper, bought a 30-acre plot in 1679, and the place was known as Miller’s Place by the early 1700s.
History and shoreline. The same article notes that the Miller Place Historic District on North Country Road was the first historic district in the Town of Brookhaven when it was listed on the National Register in 1976, and that the hamlet has about two miles of North Shore beach, with Cordwood Landing County Park trails leading down to the water. The listing gives Woodland Road as the cross street.
Getting around. The OneHome listing page shows a walk score of 11 out of 100 and a transit score of 67.
What Stands Out in the Listing
Finished lower level. The full basement is finished, per the data.
Two-car garage. Attached, with a private driveway.
Outdoor space. A deck, a fire pit area and vinyl fencing, per the listing.
A bath count to check. Three baths in the remarks, five in the data.
Next Steps for 21 Rustic Road
View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Elite, Louis Reyes · OneKey MLS #1070333. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Street View image: Google, October 2013. Map data © Google.
Sources
- OneKey MLS listing #1070333 on OneHome
- Educators Realty IDX page for the listing
- Coldwell Banker Homes page, current listing and sale record
- Coldwell Banker Homes page, 2024 listing MLS L3590152
- Raveis record of the 2024 listing
- Earlier listing video, Video Studio by Compass on YouTube
- Miller Place, New York, Wikipedia
