123 Johns Neck Road, Shirley — Home Profile

Illustrated drawing of 123 Johns Neck Road, Shirley, New York, made for the Maison Pawli Home Profile. A representation of the home, not a photograph.For Sale

$699,990 List Price · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Full Baths · 1,386 Sq Ft · 0.75 Acres · 1970 Year Built

Google Street View near 123 Johns Neck Road, Shirley, NY. The view and imagery date may differ from the property today. © Google.

123 Johns Neck Road is a 1970 waterfront ranch on a 0.75 acre double lot in Shirley, listed at $699,990 as a new listing. The remarks place it on a protected creek adjoining Narrow Bay, 1.1 miles from Smith Point Park, with protected wetlands directly across the water where building is prohibited, and describe a catwalk and boat slip with allowances for a floating dock.

Inside, the remarks describe an open plan under cathedral ceilings with nine skylights, a separate wing with its own entrance, slate kitchen counters, new windows and a 19 by 12 foot year-round sunroom with hydronic floor heat. The sections below set out the data and the waterfront, flood and solar questions a buyer would raise.

Property Details

The Basics

  • Style: Ranch
  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 2 full
  • Living Area: 1,386 sq ft
  • Lot Size: 0.75 acres, described as a double lot
  • Year Built: 1970
  • Rooms: 8 in total
  • Interior: Open floor plan, cathedral ceilings, 9 skylights, new windows per the remarks
  • Separate wing: With its own entrance per the remarks
  • Kitchen: Slate countertops per the remarks (the listing data lists granite and stone counters), electric range
  • Sunroom: 19 x 12 ft, year-round, with a split unit and hydronic floor heating
  • Basement: Crawl space
  • Garage: Oversized 2-car with storage attic, plus an attached tool and boat shed
  • Outdoor: Upper and lower decks; new dining room sliders
  • Waterfront: Creek frontage with a catwalk and boat slip; the remarks say a floating dock is allowed
  • HOA: None listed

Systems & Utilities

  • Heating: Oil, hot water baseboard, with solar per the listing data; hydronic floor heat in the sunroom
  • Cooling: Wall or window units, plus a split unit in the sunroom
  • Solar: Owned panels per the remarks, which cite $111 per month
  • Floor elevation: The remarks cite a 4 ft floor elevation
  • Laundry: In the garage
  • Sewer: Cesspool and septic tank per the listing data
  • Water: Public
  • Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.

Creek, Slip and Dock Questions

The listing records canal and creek access and a boat slip and dock, and the remarks describe launching a boat, canoe or kayak from the back yard with access to Moriches Bay and the Great South Bay. The statement that a floating dock is allowed is the seller’s. A buyer would ask for any town and state permits covering the catwalk, slip and any future dock, check whether the shoreline and the wetlands across the creek carry New York State DEC tidal wetland restrictions, and have a licensed attorney review the survey and any riparian or underwater land rights.

Flood Elevation and Solar

The remarks cite a 4 ft floor elevation but the listing does not state a flood zone, an elevation certificate or a flood insurance cost. On a tidal creek near Narrow Bay those are central questions, and a buyer would obtain the elevation certificate and an insurance quote early. The solar panels are described as owned, with a figure of $111 per month that the listing does not explain; a buyer would ask what that amount represents and request the installation records and any warranty in writing.

Wildlife and Wetlands

The remarks describe deer, egrets, herons, ospreys and eagles, and protected wetlands directly across the creek where building is prohibited. Much of western Shirley lies within the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, per Wikipedia. The prohibition on building across the water is the listing’s statement and would be confirmed through the town and DEC.

Listing History and Public Records

OneHome showed the listing as new, with 3 days on OneHome, 43 photos and no open house scheduled when the page was read. A public IDX copy of the listing showed 3 days on market, no flood zone and no video or virtual tour. The listing gives Livingston Drive as the cross street, with directions from William Floyd Parkway east on Parkview Drive to Johns Neck Road. No video or 3D tour was found on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook or TikTok.

Tax & Financial Data

Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.

  • List Price: $699,990
  • Price Per Sq Ft: about $505
  • Annual Property Tax: $9,741 (tax year 2026, per the listing)
  • Tax Assessed Value: $2,250 (per the listing)
  • Tax ID: 0200-983-30-12-00-018-001
  • MLS#: 1066422

The remarks describe a double lot. A buyer would confirm whether it is assessed as one tax parcel or two.

School District

The listing places the address in the William Floyd school district and names these schools.

  • Elementary: John S. Hobart Elementary School
  • Middle School: William Paca Middle School
  • High School: William Floyd High School

School boundaries are for reference only and can change. Enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.

The Neighborhood

Location. Shirley is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven on the South Shore, with 26,360 residents at the 2020 census, per Wikipedia. It is named for developer Walter T. Shirley, who began developing the Mastic Bay area in the 1940s. Smith Point County Park, which the remarks put 1.1 miles away, is Suffolk County’s largest park, on the east end of Fire Island, reached by the William Floyd Parkway over Narrow Bay on the Smith Point Bridge, per Wikipedia. The park holds the TWA Flight 800 memorial, dedicated in 2004.

Getting around. The OneHome listing page shows a walk score of 54 out of 100, a bike score of 27 and a transit score of 84.

What Stands Out in the Listing

A slip on the creek. A catwalk and boat slip, with water access toward Narrow Bay.

Protected land across the water. The remarks say building is prohibited on the wetlands opposite.

Nine skylights. Under cathedral ceilings throughout.

Owned solar. Panels described as owned rather than leased.

Next Steps for 123 Johns Neck Road

View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.

Listing courtesy of Your Team D&G Realty Ltd., Amy Schuler · OneKey MLS #1066422. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.

Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. No Street View image is used because the house is hidden by trees in the available imagery.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply