436 Bay Avenue, Patchogue — Home Profile

Illustrated drawing of 436 Bay Avenue, Patchogue, New York, made for the Maison Pawli Home Profile. A representation of the home, not a photograph.For Sale

$900,000 · 7 Beds · 2 Baths · 3,109 sq ft · 0.65 Acres · 1890 Victorian · Patchogue Village · OneKey MLS #1069323

Google Street View near 436 Bay Avenue, Patchogue, NY. The view and imagery date may differ from the property today. © Google.

A seven-bedroom Victorian built in 1890 on 0.65 acres in the Village of Patchogue, listed at $900,000. The remarks describe it as an estate-style property with potential for a full reimagining, and list original hardwood floors on three levels, crown moldings, arched doorways, stained glass, two marble fireplaces and decorative ceiling frescoes.

The grounds are described just as specifically: a cobblestone entrance and driveway leading to a three-car garage, gates, fencing, slate walkways, a concrete gazebo, fountains and statues, and a separate small cottage with a kitchen, bath and loft. The listing carries a note that some of its photos were digitally altered, which makes the property itself the better guide than the pictures.

Property Details

The Basics

  • Property type: Single Family Residence (Victorian)
  • Bedrooms: 7
  • Bathrooms: 2 full
  • Living area: 3,109 sq ft
  • Lot size: 0.65 acres
  • Year built: 1890
  • Garage: 3 spaces
  • Construction: shake siding
  • Other structure: a small cottage with kitchen, bath and loft, per the remarks
  • Porch: wraparound porch and a patio off the parlor, per the remarks
  • HOA: none
  • Cross streets: 500 Bay Ave and Smith St

Systems & Utilities

  • Heating: oil
  • Cooling: none
  • Sewer: cesspool
  • Water: public
  • Utilities: electricity and water connected
  • Basement: not stated in the listing
  • Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.

Photographs Altered to Show Potential

The remarks end with a notice that some photos “have been photoshopped to show the potential of the home grounds.” In practical terms, the listing images may not match the current condition of the yard, gardens or exterior. A buyer who is relying on the online gallery should compare it to what is visible on site and to a current survey.

The Cottage and the Count of Kitchens and Baths

The remarks describe a separate small cottage with its own kitchen, bath and loft. The listing does not say whether it is legal as a dwelling, whether it has a certificate of occupancy, or how it is counted in the 3,109 sq ft. Village zoning for accessory dwellings and for two kitchens on one lot is a question for the Village of Patchogue building department and for an attorney.

A 136-Year-Old House With Original Detail

The house is listed as built in 1890, with stained glass, marble fireplaces and ceiling frescoes mentioned as original or period details in the remarks. Older houses of this kind raise a standard set of inspection items: knob-and-tube or older wiring, plaster condition, window repair and lead paint disclosure for pre-1978 construction. The listing reports an oil heating system and no cooling. Any restoration or exterior change may also be subject to village review, which the listing does not address.

Two Tax Lines on One Bill

The remarks break the total tax into Brookhaven and Patchogue Village components. The two components in the remarks add up to more than the total the remarks give. See the Tax section for the figures.

Listing History and Public Records

The listing is active at $900,000 and showed 6 days on OneHome when it was researched. Price and tax history panels on OneHome require a sign-in and did not show figures, so no prior sale is reported. The house is listed as built in 1890, and no outside historic record was verified for this profile.

Tax & Financial Data

Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.

  • List Price: $900,000
  • Price Per Sq Ft: about $289
  • Annual Taxes (total, per the listing): $15,969 (2026)
  • Remarks breakdown: Brookhaven $12,979.56 and Patchogue Village $3,276.08 (these two figures add up to $16,255.64, which differs from the stated total)
  • Assessed Value: $3,000 (as shown on the listing)
  • Tax ID: 0204-020-00-04-00-021-003
  • MLS#: 1069323

The stated total and the two components in the remarks do not match, so the tax figure should be confirmed with the Town of Brookhaven receiver of taxes and the Village of Patchogue before any decision.

School District

The listing names the Patchogue-Medford school district, with Bay Elementary School, South Ocean Middle School and Patchogue-Medford High School. School assignment and eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.

The Neighborhood

The Village of Patchogue incorporated in 1893 and sits on Patchogue Bay, part of the Great South Bay, according to Wikipedia. The same entry says the Patchogue Theatre opened in 1923, was acquired by the village in the mid-1990s and refurbished, and now seats 1,166. The Patchogue LIRR station on the Montauk Branch is near downtown, and the Davis Park Ferry Company runs Patchogue-Watch Hill and Patchogue-Davis Park routes to Fire Island from terminals within walking distance of the station. OneHome shows a Walk Score of 78, a Bike Score of 47 and a Transit Score of 80.

What Stands Out in the Listing

Period detail named in the remarks. Stained glass, marble fireplaces, crown moldings and ceiling frescoes are listed.

0.65 acres in a village. Land of this size inside the village is unusual enough that the survey and zoning deserve early attention.

A cottage on the lot. Its legal status is not stated in the listing.

Altered photos disclosed. The listing says some photos were digitally changed to show potential.

Oil heat, no cooling, cesspool. Systems that a buyer should price into any restoration plan.

Next Steps for 436 Bay Avenue

View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.

Listing courtesy of BH&G R E Realty Connect, JoAnn Spatola E-PRO PSA · OneKey MLS #1069323. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.

Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. No Street View image is used because a tall hedge blocks the Google Street View frame and only the roofline of the house is visible.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply