24 Sylvan Lane, Miller Place — Home Profile
$899,000 List Price · 5 Bedrooms · 4 Full Baths · 3,079 Sq Ft · 0.48 Acres · 1922 Year Built
24 Sylvan Lane is a 1922 colonial on 0.48 acres in Miller Place, listed at $899,000. The listing describes five bedrooms, four full baths and 3,079 square feet, with a fenced yard, a 16 by 32 foot freeform Gunite pool, a heated garage and a lower-level apartment that the remarks call a legal accessory apartment. The listing dates major renovations to 2019.
The sections below set out the listing data, the apartment and systems details, the school district and the items a buyer would confirm independently before relying on them.
Property Details
The Basics
- Style: Colonial
- Bedrooms: 5 (including a first-floor bedroom with a full bath)
- Bathrooms: 4 full
- Living Area: 3,079 sq ft
- Lot Size: 0.48 acres
- Year Built: 1922, with major renovations in 2019 per the listing
- Garage: 1-car, oversized, heated and air-conditioned per the remarks
- Basement: Finished
- Fireplace: Wood-burning, plus a wood-burning stove per the remarks
- Pool: In-ground Gunite, fenced, with a cover and an outdoor shower
- HOA: None
Systems & Utilities
- Heating: Oil, five zones per the remarks
- Cooling: Central air plus ductless mini splits, including one in the garage
- Backup power: Propane automatic generator, per the remarks
- Water: Public, with a whole-house filtration system per the remarks
- Sewer: Cesspool. The remarks cite five cesspools, three of them new.
- Roof: Described as a lifetime transferable roof
- Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel.
The Lower-Level Apartment
The remarks describe a legal accessory apartment on the lower level, and the listing data shows an in-law floor plan and two kitchens. The word “legal” is the listing’s, and the status of any accessory apartment depends on Town of Brookhaven permits and a certificate of occupancy, along with the property’s septic capacity. A buyer would ask for the documents and confirm the status with the town building department and a licensed attorney. Rental income from an apartment is not guaranteed and is not projected here.
Listing History and Public Records
OneHome shows 37 days on OneHome when the page was read and 43 photos. An IDX copy of the listing shows no video or virtual tour, and a web search for the address found none. The listing remarks describe the rear of the property as backing the former Old Girl Scout Property, a detail that a buyer would confirm against the survey and town records.
Tax & Financial Data
Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the Town of Brookhaven Tax Receiver before closing.
- List Price: $899,000
- Price Per Sq Ft: about $292
- Annual Property Tax: $17,262 (tax year 2026, per the listing; verify at brookhavenny.gov)
- Tax ID: 0200-027-00-03-00-008-000
- MLS#: 1048589
- Town: Brookhaven
- School District: Miller Place
School District
The listing places the address in the Miller Place school district and names these schools.
- Elementary: Andrew Muller Primary School
- Middle School: North Country Road School
- High School: Miller Place High School
School boundaries are for reference only and can change. Enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district at millerplace.k12.ny.us.
The Neighborhood
Location. Miller Place is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven on Long Island’s North Shore, settled in 1664 by buyers from Setauket, per Wikipedia. The listing gives North Country Road as the cross street and these directions: North Country Road to Sylvan Lane, on the north side.
The hamlet. Miller Place had 11,723 residents at the 2020 census and borders Mount Sinai Harbor. Per Wikipedia, it has a two-mile stretch of beach, Cordwood Landing County Park with wooded trails down to Cedar Beach, and the Miller Place Academy, built in 1834 and now home to a free library.
Getting around. The OneHome listing page shows a walk score of 11 out of 100 (almost all errands require a car) and a transit score of 73.
What Stands Out in the Listing
A 1922 house with a 2019 renovation record. The listing dates the major work, which a buyer can match against permits.
A pool and outdoor shower. The Gunite pool was refinished with new marble dust, per the remarks.
A heated garage. The garage is heated and air-conditioned, with its own mini split and a washer and dryer hookup.
Cathedral and beamed ceilings. The interior list includes beamed, cathedral and high ceilings, hardwood floors and cedar-lined closets.
A catwalk upstairs. The remarks describe a catwalk leading to two additional bedrooms.
Next Steps for 24 Sylvan Lane
View all listing photos and schedule a showing through the official listing page.
Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna Coach, Linda Stowell · OneKey MLS #1048589. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Street View image: Google, August 2024. Map data © Google.
