238 Shore Road, Mount Sinai — Home Profile
For Sale $1,350,000 List Price · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Full Baths + 1 Half · 1,970 Sq Ft · 1.11 Acres · 1952 Year Built
238 Shore Road is a 1952 split-level on 1.11 acres directly on Mount Sinai Harbor, listed at $1,350,000. The data gives three bedrooms, two full baths and a half bath across 1,970 square feet on three or more levels, with a west-facing aspect and panoramic water views. The remarks describe undeveloped Town land on one side, a wooded buffer on the other, a two-tiered composite deck with a roll-out awning, and a kayak and boat rack a few feet from the water.
The house is small for its land and its frontage, and the seller has drafted expansion plans, per the remarks. That pairing puts waterfront permitting, the flood zone and the cesspool at the top of the list of items to confirm.
Property Details
The Basics
- Style: Mid-Century Modern, Split-Level per the data
- Bedrooms: 3; the third, on its own level, is used as a great room or junior suite per the remarks
- Bathrooms: 2 full and 1 half; the remarks say the powder room could be converted to a full bath
- Living Area: 1,970 sq ft (source: public records)
- Rooms: 6 total
- Lot Size: 1.11 acres (48,352 sq ft per an IDX copy of the listing)
- Year Built: 1952
- Kitchen: Oak cabinetry, granite counters, new stainless appliances, GE Cafe induction range with double convection oven per the remarks
- Primary suite: French doors to a Juliet balcony, walk-in closet, en-suite bath
- Fireplace: Brick, wood burning, in the living room
- Flooring: Hardwood on the main and upper levels, plus tile and laminate
- Basement: Partial, storage
- Garage: Attached 2-car tandem with lower-level access and a walkout, per the remarks
- Outdoor: Two-tiered composite deck with awning, patio, outdoor shower, storage shed, kayak and boat rack
- Waterfront: Yes, on Mount Sinai Harbor, with water access; no dock is listed
- View: Panoramic, water, trees
- Construction: Frame with vinyl siding, architectural roof
- HOA: None
Systems & Utilities
- Heating: Forced air, oil
- Cooling: Central air
- Water: Public
- Sewer: Cesspool
- Windows: Casement, insulated
- Energy: ENERGY STAR qualified appliances per the data
- Utilities: Cable, electricity and public water connected; public trash collection
- Road: Public, maintained
- Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.
Harbor Frontage Questions
The listing puts the property directly on Mount Sinai Harbor and names a kayak and boat rack near the water, but it lists no dock and gives no frontage measurement. A buyer would ask whether any dock or mooring is permitted, what Town of Brookhaven and New York State DEC rules apply to work near the shoreline, and where the property line meets the high-water mark; a licensed attorney would review the survey and any riparian rights. PropertyShark shows FEMA flood zones AE and X on the parcel. That is a third-party reading, not a listing statement, so the flood zone, the elevation certificate and the insurance cost would be confirmed directly.
The Expansion Plans
The remarks say the seller has professionally drafted expansion plans available to share. Plans are not approvals. On a waterfront parcel with a cesspool and possible flood-zone frontage, an addition can turn on setbacks, wetlands permits, sanitary-system upgrades under Suffolk County health rules and flood-elevation requirements. A buyer would ask for the plans, ask whether anything has been filed with the town, and have an architect or attorney review what could be built.
Open House Media
The listing’s co-marketing includes an Instagram reel posted November 5, 2026 by Francheska Markman of Coldwell Banker American Homes announcing the November 7 open house, with a matching Facebook video. Neither the OneHome page nor the brokerage page links a video or 3D tour. The first OneHome photo is marked “AI enhanced,” so a buyer would compare the photos with the house in person.
Listing History and Public Records
OneHome shows the listing as new, with 2 days on OneHome when the page was read, 41 photos, three listing documents and one open house on Saturday, November 7, 2026 from 12:00 to 2:00 PM. The data notes that the seller will consider concessions. PropertyShark records a sale on August 18, 2004 for $744,900 and a later deed dated July 29, 2013 with no sale price shown.
Tax & Financial Data
Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.
- List Price: $1,350,000
- Price Per Sq Ft: about $685
- Annual Property Tax: $18,099 (tax year 2026, per the listing)
- Tax Assessed Value: $4,050 (per the listing)
- Tax ID: 0200-046-00-03-00-003-000
- MLS#: 1069525
The tax figure comes from the listing and would be confirmed with the Town of Brookhaven receiver of taxes before closing.
School District
The listing places the address in the Mount Sinai school district and names these schools.
- Elementary: Mt Sinai Elementary School
- Middle School: Mt Sinai Middle School
- High School: Robert M. Grable Jr. Mount Sinai High School
School boundaries are for reference only and can change. Enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district.
The Neighborhood
Location. Mount Sinai is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven with 11,623 residents at the 2020 census, per Wikipedia. The area was called Old Mans until the 1840s; the present name has been in use since about 1841.
The harbor. The same article says the mouth of Mount Sinai Harbor was moved to the west side in the mid-1800s, that the harbor once supported shellfishing, waterfowl hunting and salt hay harvesting, and that commercial fishermen still work from it. Cedar Beach, on the peninsula between the harbor and Long Island Sound, includes a marine sanctuary and nature preserve. An early 19th-century Methodist church once stood on Shore Road.
Getting around. The OneHome listing page shows a walk score of 11 out of 100 and a transit score of 46.
What Stands Out in the Listing
On the harbor. Directly on Mount Sinai Harbor, with west-facing water and sunset views per the listing.
Open land beside it. Undeveloped Town land on one side and a wooded buffer on the other, per the remarks.
A flexible lower level. The third bedroom has a wet bar, built-ins, a powder room and sliders to the patio.
Plans on file with the seller. Drafted expansion plans are available, per the remarks.
Next Steps for 238 Shore Road
View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker American Homes, Dawn M. Viola · OneKey MLS #1069525. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. No Street View image is used because the August 2024 imagery from Shore Road shows trees and lawn, with the house hidden.
