69 Hillside Drive E, Sag Harbor — Home Profile

Illustrated drawing of 69 Hillside Drive E, Sag Harbor, New York, made for the Maison Pawli Home Profile. A representation of the home, not a photograph.For Sale

$1,599,000 · 5 Bedrooms · 5 Full, 2 Half Baths · 3,843 sq ft · Ranch (existing structure) · 0.23 Acres

Google Street View near 69 Hillside Drive E, Sag Harbor, NY. The view and imagery date may differ from the property today. © Google.

69 Hillside Drive E in Sag Harbor is a 0.23-acre property listed in OneKey MLS at $1,599,000 with a description of a proposed new house: about 3,843 square feet, five bedrooms, five full baths and two half baths, designed by Hamptons architect Peter Cook. The remarks say the plans are approved for a new single-family home by the Suffolk County Department of Health Services (septic) and the Sag Harbor Village Architectural Review Board, with a 10-by-20-foot in-ground pool and pool house included.

The structured fields describe something different from the remarks: a ranch built in 1954, forced-air propane heat, central air and an in-ground pool. Public pages for the same address show a 1954 cottage-scale house in Street View imagery and an earlier listing history that includes a sale in 2022. The profile below keeps the proposed house and the existing house separate, because a buyer needs to know which one the price describes.

Property Details

The Basics

  • Style: Ranch in the structured fields; the remarks describe a contemporary design by architect Peter Cook
  • Year built: 1954 (existing structure per the fields)
  • Bedrooms: 5, per the remarks and fields
  • Bathrooms: 7 (5 full, 2 half)
  • Living area: 3,843 sq ft, described as including a fully finished lower level
  • Lot size: 0.23 acres
  • Rooms total: 15
  • Basement: full; the remarks describe a lower level with a playroom, gym area, an ensuite bedroom, a full bath and two egress points
  • Fireplace: 1; the remarks place it in the primary suite
  • Pool: in-ground; the remarks describe a 10-by-20-foot pool, a pool house, an outdoor shower, a sunken courtyard and an outdoor kitchen
  • Parking: driveway, garage with opener, off-street
  • Water access: yes; view listed as trees/woods and water; the remarks mention walking distance to private Nineveh Beach access
  • Flooring: wood
  • Appliances listed: dryer, dishwasher, oven, refrigerator, stainless steel appliances, washer

Systems & Utilities

  • Heating: forced air, propane
  • Cooling: central air
  • Sewer: septic tank (the remarks cite Suffolk County Department of Health Services approval for a septic system)
  • Water source: public
  • Utilities listed: electricity connected, sewer connected
  • Foundation: concrete perimeter; construction materials: frame
  • HOA: none
  • Internet: the page lists fiber at 940 to 8,000 Mbps and several fixed wireless and satellite options, subject to address-level confirmation
  • Flood Zone: Not stated in the listing. Confirm the FEMA map panel for the parcel and request an elevation certificate and current flood insurance quote.

Approved Plans, Existing House: What the Price Describes

The first line of the remarks reads “Approved to be built for 3,843 square feet new residential single-family home,” and the description then reads as a finished house. The structured fields list a 1954 ranch. A public copy of an earlier listing, on Hamptons Real Estate (Vincent Horcasitas, Saunders), describes land with an existing three-bedroom, two-bath house on 0.23 acres plus a building permit for a proposed new home, and says the plans were still being submitted to the town at that time. The earlier page’s headline calls the land fully permitted, which does not match its own remarks.

A buyer can ask for the approved Architectural Review Board resolution, the Building Department permit, the Suffolk County Department of Health Services septic approval, the survey and the status of the existing house. Whether the approvals run with the land or the plans, and how long they remain valid, is a question for a real estate attorney and the Village of Sag Harbor. This point may need attorney review.

Earlier Listings and Sale History

Per Zillow’s page for the address, the property sold on November 19, 2021 for $999,000 and again on April 20, 2022 for $1,475,000. Listings followed at $1,595,000 on October 29, 2024, at $1,695,000 in April and May 2025, a price change to $1,490,000 on September 9, 2025, a pending status on January 22, 2026 and a removal on May 7, 2026. The current listing was entered on November 6, 2026 at $1,599,000.

A Saunders & Associates flipbook titled for the address was published on Issuu on October 5, 2025; the page text itself does not show its contents. This history is public-record context only and says nothing about why a prior contract ended.

Nineveh Beach and the Historic District Nearby

The remarks mention a short walk to private Nineveh Beach access. The area around Hillside Drive sits close to the Sag Harbor Hills, Azurest and Ninevah Beach subdivisions, which the Wikipedia article on Sag Harbor says were listed as a historic district on July 10, 2019. Whether this parcel lies inside the district boundary is not stated in the listing and can be checked with the Village of Sag Harbor. Beach access described as private usually comes with membership, ownership or easement terms that a title review would confirm.

Listing History and Public Records

OneHome shows a list price of $1,599,000, a New Listing banner and 3 days on OneHome. The price and tax history tables on the OneHome page show placeholder values to a visitor who is not signed in, so the history here comes from Zillow’s public page: sold $150,000 on November 15, 2000; sold $999,000 on November 19, 2021; sold $1,475,000 on April 20, 2022; listed October 29, 2024 at $1,595,000; listed April 2025 at $1,695,000; price change to $1,490,000 on September 9, 2025; pending January 22, 2026; removed May 7, 2026; listed again November 6, 2026 at $1,599,000. OneHome shows 9 photos and no open houses.

Tax & Financial Data

Figures come from the OneKey MLS listing. Tax amounts should be confirmed with the town tax receiver before closing.

  • List Price: $1,599,000
  • Price Per Sq Ft: about $416
  • Annual property taxes: $4,570 (tax year 2026, per the listing)
  • Tax assessed value: $3,850 (per the listing)
  • Estimated monthly cost shown on OneHome: $9,158
  • Tax ID: 0302-004-00-02-00-030-000
  • MLS#: 1071383

The tax figure reflects the existing property as assessed. A newly built or substantially rebuilt house can be reassessed, so the current bill is not a forecast of future taxes. Confirm with the Town of Southampton Receiver of Taxes.

School District

Per the listing, the home is in the Sag Harbor school district. The named schools are Sag Harbor Elementary School and Pierson Middle/High School. School assignment depends on district boundaries and should be confirmed directly with the district.

The Neighborhood

Sag Harbor is an incorporated village on eastern Long Island, incorporated on March 26, 1846, with 2,772 residents at the 2020 census, according to Wikipedia’s Sag Harbor entry. The village lies partly in the Town of Southampton and partly in the Town of East Hampton. It was declared an official U.S. port of entry in 1789, whaling peaked in the 1840s, and the Long Island Rail Road opened a Sag Harbor branch in 1870. The OneHome page shows a Walk Score of 82, a Bike Score of 81 and a Transit Score of 87.

What Stands Out in the Listing

Designer named in the remarks. The remarks credit Peter Cook as the architect of the planned house.

Existing house versus approved plans. Fields list a 1954 ranch; the remarks describe a new house, so the two need to be reconciled.

Pool and outdoor spaces. A 10-by-20-foot in-ground pool, pool house, outdoor shower, sunken courtyard and outdoor kitchen are in the remarks.

Finished lower level. Playroom, gym area, an ensuite bedroom, a full bath and two egress points are described.

Propane heat and septic. Forced-air propane heating, central air, a septic tank and public water are listed.

Next Steps for 69 Hillside Drive E

View the listing details and request a showing through the official listing page.

Listing courtesy of ZI Realty LLC, Muhittin U. Ilkay · OneKey MLS #1071383. Data sourced from OneKey MLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified independently. For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.

Placeholder graphic created for this profile. Not a photograph of the property. The Street View image is not used because it shows an older cottage that does not match the new house described in the remarks.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply