15405 Main Road, Mattituck — A 1765 Colonial, Completely Reinvented
There are old houses, and then there are homes like 15405 Main Road. Built in 1765 — making it one of the oldest residential properties you’ll encounter on the North Fork — this four-bedroom colonial has been thoughtfully brought into the present without surrendering what makes it irreplaceable. The exposed beams are still there. So are the wide plank hardwood floors and the salvaged vintage tile. What’s new is everything that makes it livable: a chef’s kitchen with high-end appliances, radiant heated floors, central air, and a spa-caliber primary bath.
Set on 0.71 acres in Mattituck’s historic hamlet core, just off Village Lane, this is a genuinely rare convergence — authentic pre-Revolutionary architecture, a complete modern renovation, and one of the North Fork’s most sought-after addresses. This profile compiles the verified property data, tax history, school district details, and neighborhood context to help you evaluate it clearly.
Property Details
The Basics
- StyleColonial
- ConstructionShingle Siding, Frame
- Bedrooms4
- Full Baths3
- Total Rooms10
- Living Area2,754 sq ft
- Lot Size0.71 acres (30,492 sq ft)
- Year Built1765
- Year Renovated2023
- ConditionUpdated / Remodeled
- Garage2-Car Detached
- ParkingPrivate Driveway
- BasementUnfinished
- AtticFull, Walk-Up
- FireplaceYes (1, Living Room)
- FlooringWide Plank Hardwood
- PoolNo — Room Available
- HOANone
Systems & Utilities
- CoolingCentral Air
- HeatNatural Gas — Forced Air, Hot Water, Radiant
- WaterPublic
- SewerCesspool
- ElectricPSEG
- Flood ZoneZone X — Out of SFHA
- Water AccessYes
- WaterfrontNo
Key Interior Features
- KitchenChef’s kitchen, breakfast bar, open layout, high-end appliances
- Primary SuitePrimary bathroom, walk-in closet
- Main Floor1st floor bedroom, 1st floor full bath, formal dining room, entrance foyer
- CharacterExposed beamed ceilings, crown molding, natural woodwork, original details, salvaged vintage tile
- ComfortHeated floors, eat-in kitchen, storage throughout
- OutdoorMahogany deck, garden, outbuilding, partial fencing, in-ground sprinklers
- LaundryInside
- ExclusionsSonos system
Tax & Financial Data
Sourced from Suffolk County municipal records and OneKey MLS. All figures should be independently verified.
Tax ID: 1000-114-00-06-00-003-000 | Suffolk County, Town of Southold | Zoning: R-40 | Exemption: Homestead
School District
Mattituck-Cutchogue is a small, community-rooted district serving the North Fork’s historic hamlet core. With modest enrollment and a focus on individual student development, it offers the kind of educational environment that’s increasingly hard to find — where teachers know students by name and community involvement is genuinely high.
The Neighborhood
Wine Country Address
Mattituck sits at the heart of Long Island Wine Country. Dozens of acclaimed North Fork wineries are within a short drive, making weekend afternoons an entirely different experience than anything the South Shore offers.
Water Access Nearby
The property itself carries a Water Access designation, and Mattituck Inlet — a boater’s gateway to the Long Island Sound — is just minutes away. This is waterfront-adjacent living without the waterfront insurance premium.
Historic Village Core
Village Lane and Main Road put you at the center of Mattituck’s small-town character — local shops, the historic Love Lane corridor, and a genuine sense of place that draws buyers who are done with suburban anonymity.
East End Connectivity
Route 25 (Main Road) connects directly to Riverhead and beyond, while the LIRR’s Mattituck station makes the commute to New York City viable for those who need it. Greenport, Shelter Island, and the Hamptons are all within reasonable reach.
What Makes This Home Stand Out
Built in 1765 — Fully Renovated in 2023
Pre-Revolutionary construction with a ground-up modern renovation is extraordinarily rare on Long Island. Most buyers have to choose between historic character and modern livability. This home doesn’t ask you to choose. The exposed beams, wide plank floors, and original details coexist with a chef’s kitchen, radiant heat, central air, and fully updated baths.
First-Floor Bedroom and Full Bath
A ground-level bedroom with its own full bath is a feature that matters for multi-generational families, guests, or anyone planning ahead. It’s increasingly rare in homes of any era, and here it’s paired with 10 total rooms — genuine living space by any measure.
Radiant Heated Floors — Gas Heat — No Oil
Natural gas radiant heat is a meaningful upgrade over the oil systems that dominate older North Fork homes. Underfloor radiant in particular delivers a comfort level that forced-air simply can’t match — and eliminates the ongoing cost volatility of oil delivery on the East End.
Exceptionally Low Taxes for the North Fork
At $8,555 annually, the property tax burden here is well below what comparable homes in the Hamptons or even western Suffolk carry. For a home priced just under $1.15M in one of Long Island’s most desirable hamlets, this is a meaningful financial advantage that compounds over time.
Room for a Pool on 0.71 Acres
The listing explicitly notes pool potential, and the lot — nearly three-quarters of an acre in a hamlet where space commands a premium — supports it. The detached two-car garage also offers flexibility as a studio, workshop, or home gym conversion without touching the main house footprint.
